The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GhostPants]

-snip-

just because the toxic is 2008 does not mean this is an unfair trade to them, as they're likely asking for advice based on the Rares List.
so, based on what I see here the UR Dog is worth a yellow toxic+ a balloon dog, and a balloon is worth 3 blue rose's, meaning the UR Dog is worth a yellow toxic+3 blue roses technically, making this trade unfair to them by a little over a blue rose's worth.

as for demand, it's always up to the user. If you want my personal opinion based off of trades I have seen in the past (which should be taken very lightly btw), the UR Dog doesn't have the best demand, but can still usually get close to what it's worth. again, depends on the user. hope this helped xx I'd get a second opinion if you can.

Thank you so much!! this really helped (:

[dakotapaws]

is this fair?

id love a second opinion c:

[Ironic Equation]

TD BA = Mountain zebra
With demand of both factored in?

[Horror]

TD BA = Mountain zebra
With demand of both factored in?

demand is already factored in the ba's list placement, it's only worth the same as it's littermates and technically should just be a mid advent itself

if you choose to re-apply "demand" onto that again or you care about "true dates", then that's completely up to you and your partner to decide if you're both happy with the trade or not

[patriciaツ]

TD BA = Mountain zebra
With demand of both factored in?

demand is already factored in the ba's list placement, it's only worth the same as it's littermates and technically should just be a mid advent itself

if you choose to re-apply "demand" onto that again or you care about "true dates", then that's completely up to you and your partner to decide if you're both happy with the trade or not

^^ was about to post, but they phrased it better

[.wren.]

is this fair?

id love a second opinion c:

a 2010 uncommon is worth 7-10 c$ alone, according to this guide. (disclaimer- they do not have set values, this is just a guide reflecting their worth) so you would already be overpaying with just your two 2010 uncommons. this trade is unfair to you :>

[Xeroxoe]

Hows this? Thank you in advance! xxx

[ghostbite]

Is this fair? Thank you for the help in advance!

[Puptarts]

Hows this? Thank you in advance! xxx

i believe their side is worth around 50-90c$ so unfair to you, uncommons don't have a set worth in c$ though so this is going off of this list

Is this fair? Thank you for the help in advance!

a late 2010 rare is worth 20-25 c$ so yes this is fair

[Mishi23]

Is this trade fair? Thank you!