The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Puptarts]

NonTag + White July = Coontail?

[GhostPants]

Is a yellow toxic fair for a marionette dog ^^?
I know the demand is very high for those little things ^^;
New trade! How is it ^^?
Oh and, low sept + ?? = Patchwork
- Gasoline

[mediocre mackerel]

bid
bid2
bid3
bid4
Ice blue swirl bids, which would you accept out of these? <3
Thanks for any help!!! ^^

[boston]

bid
bid2
bid3
bid4
Ice blue swirl bids, which would you accept out of these? <3
Thanks for any help!!! ^^

personally i'd accept your first bid c:

[Puptarts]

bid
bid2
bid3
bid4
Ice blue swirl bids, which would you accept out of these? <3
Thanks for any help!!! ^^

i would accept #1 personally

[patriciaツ]

bid
bid2
bid3
bid4
Ice blue swirl bids, which would you accept out of these? <3
Thanks for any help!!! ^^

personally i'd accept your first bid c:

all bids but bid two are quite a bit of overpay, depends on whether you value pets or $c more

[.wren.]

Is a yellow toxic fair for a marionette dog ^^?
I know the demand is very high for those little things ^^;
Got this trade, how is the demand for the UR dog?
Oh and, low sept + ?? = Patchwork
- Gasoline

Hmm... I’m pretty sure this isn’t very fair for you... The toxic dog is a 2008 Halloween, and those go for a lot... Who am I though, it is your choice!

just because the toxic is 2008 does not mean this is an unfair trade to them, as they're likely asking for advice based on the Rares List.
so, based on what I see here the UR Dog is worth a yellow toxic+ a balloon dog, and a balloon is worth 3 blue rose's, meaning the UR Dog is worth a yellow toxic+3 blue roses technically, making this trade unfair to them by a little over a blue rose's worth.

as for demand, it's always up to the user. If you want my personal opinion based off of trades I have seen in the past (which should be taken very lightly btw), the UR Dog doesn't have the best demand, but can still usually get close to what it's worth. again, depends on the user. hope this helped xx I'd get a second opinion if you can.

[Redpanda]

Which one is best for my UR Bee :O
XX
XX
XX

please help :3

[Puptarts]

NonTag + White July = Coontail?

[Banana.]

EDIT- I have been asking for more then 5 pages now with no response, please help ;v;

This one isnt a bulk, but I'd love to trade the pets away for Bulk!

For starters, is it fair?

And would it be easier to trade away the pets theyre offering for Bulk or the Sorb?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78812252&userid=795787&signature=bgFIlq4Eq0VUo69h6P2MGg

-

Also this! trades/viewtrade.php?id=78821198&userid=795787&signature=itK90N3qh1cuHfyswZcHgA

The chart i look at shows how many mid advents pets are worth so MA is what that means (:
I’m gonna try my best to help you.

The first one: their side adds up to 37 mid advents while the sorbet is 84 BUT the punk dog has demand, and I’m not sure how much it goes for, I only did this by rarity.

The second one: the chart doesn’t have Mid advent worth for the peach bc it said the gaps haven’t been discussed so I took the value of the sorbet and subtracted it from the bun
Bun= 331-336 ma
Sorbet= 83-84 (when subtracting I did the higher numbers)
And I got 252 which is the non tier, meaning a non would make this trade fair, and the peach is the tier below that.