The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Shigeru1992]

Hi!
I'm running an auction for red cerberus, and these are the leading bids, what do you think about them?
1
2
3

[Sorbo]

help
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78816835&userid=661736&signature=8O_RZ0t4ojgUwpy_Q3FWFA

[ɖɛɱơŋıƈ • ℘ơʂʂɛʂʂıơŋ]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78809273&userid=881902&signature=w7ck-lkwHqo0uIzbh0r25w

or is this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78808388&userid=881902&signature=ATt7pCxALC6Qz0OOHhMdww

Or this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78813495&userid=881902&signature=DSqMRqy7fYff9zsDaZZGEQ
Any help would be greatly appreciated.. I hate making people wait ^^;

[nicole3139]

Thoughts on these trades for my 2012 store pets? I'd love to make the last one work, but what would I need to make it fair if it's not already? Thank you in advance!

One
Two
Three

Thank you all so much!

For the third one, I believe if you took away one of the pets on your side (One of the horses) It would be fair rarity wise, but demand wise I think all together it can go for a bit more

For the third trade, if I added a rare February 2009 Malk cat to their side, would that make it more even?
Or if I removed one of the owls, but added a very rare Feburary 2009 Malk cat to their side, would that be even?

[LazyRainwing]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78815723&userid=651521&signature=97KmvitdKEg-h4l5dk6tQw

I just want some opinions, would any of you guys accept this???

[ɖɛɱơŋıƈ • ℘ơʂʂɛʂʂıơŋ]

Thoughts on these trades for my 2012 store pets? I'd love to make the last one work, but what would I need to make it fair if it's not already? Thank you in advance!

One
Two
Three

Thank you all so much!

For the third one, I believe if you took away one of the pets on your side (One of the horses) It would be fair rarity wise, but demand wise I think all together it can go for a bit more

For the third trade, if I added a rare February 2009 Malk cat to their side, would that make it more even?
Or if I removed one of the owls, but added a very rare Feburary 2009 Malk cat to their side, would that be even?

You can try, it depends on whether the other person values it high enough.

[Constellation.]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78809273&userid=881902&signature=w7ck-lkwHqo0uIzbh0r25w

or is this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78808388&userid=881902&signature=ATt7pCxALC6Qz0OOHhMdww

Or this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78813495&userid=881902&signature=DSqMRqy7fYff9zsDaZZGEQ
Any help would be greatly appreciated.. I hate making people wait ^^;

Trade 1:
310 C$ is equivalent to the grey dragon tier of the september list (reason I convert C$ to pets and not pets to C$ is because C$ values do not accurately reflect the value of list pets, or else upper list pets would be worth thousands of dollars worth of C$). Grey dragon is 8 mid-advents, cake dog is 6, and grinner is 2, if I remember correctly. Total the trade comes about 18 mid-advents, and the dragon is worth 11. By rarity, they're overpaying.
Trade 2:
The balloon dog is worth 21 mid-advents, and yours 11. By rarity, they're overpaying.
Trade 3:
The light leopard and mini husky are the only 2 list pets I see involved in the trade. The rest of the pets and C$ do not fill up the 8 mid-advent gap. By rarity, you're overpaying.

Overall, trades 1 and 2 are overpaying by rarity. Trade 2 is worth more by 3 mid-advents but trade 1 has nice quantity. However, by demand, you may be able to get more for you pet. Last I checked, people were valuing the blue dragon pps at a sorbet, though that may not be true now. I'd get a second opinion for demand. (:

[AuraDragoness]

For

Both are in the same tier on the advent list but, since rats have horrible demand regardless, what would have to be added with the rat to make the trade fair?

(PM me the answer so I can see it ^^)

[Swifty98]

Is this trade fair?

[ɖɛɱơŋıƈ • ℘ơʂʂɛʂʂıơŋ]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78809273&userid=881902&signature=w7ck-lkwHqo0uIzbh0r25w

or is this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78808388&userid=881902&signature=ATt7pCxALC6Qz0OOHhMdww

Or this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78813495&userid=881902&signature=DSqMRqy7fYff9zsDaZZGEQ
Any help would be greatly appreciated.. I hate making people wait ^^;

Trade 1:
310 C$ is equivalent to the grey dragon tier of the september list (reason I convert C$ to pets and not pets to C$ is because C$ values do not accurately reflect the value of list pets, or else upper list pets would be worth thousands of dollars worth of C$). Grey dragon is 8 mid-advents, cake dog is 6, and grinner is 2, if I remember correctly. Total the trade comes about 18 mid-advents, and the dragon is worth 11. By rarity, they're overpaying.
Trade 2:
The balloon dog is worth 21 mid-advents, and yours 11. By rarity, they're overpaying.
Trade 3:
The light leopard and mini husky are the only 2 list pets I see involved in the trade. The rest of the pets and C$ do not fill up the 8 mid-advent gap. By rarity, you're overpaying.

Overall, trades 1 and 2 are overpaying by rarity. Trade 2 is worth more by 3 mid-advents but trade 1 has nice quantity. However, by demand, you may be able to get more for you pet. Last I checked, people were valuing the blue dragon pps at a sorbet, though that may not be true now. I'd get a second opinion for demand. (:

Ty! Second opinion on demand?