The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[opalineteardrops]

Um hi friends, I need a little help with this Bid, I'm not very good with items or CS, and I'm a little nervous about going so far down the Mains list with this bid. But its the best one I've gotten so far and would LOVE some help with how fair it is.

BID HERE

I personally would not take it because c$ is very hard to then trade back for list pets again.

[NULL VOID]

Um hi friends, I need a little help with this Bid, I'm not very good with items or CS, and I'm a little nervous about going so far down the Mains list with this bid. But its the best one I've gotten so far and would LOVE some help with how fair it is.

BID HERE

I personally would not take it because c$ is very hard to then trade back for list pets again.

That makes sense and I have observed that in other Auctions. Thank you for reasponding! Could I get at least one more opinion please?

[Targaryen]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=78689262&userid=506060&signature=4bS7zmZfJ19AvqiyKyFEFg

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=78694808&userid=506060&signature=iqMXzH5HMtuYQ4ggyZmZbQ

Should I take either of these??

I’d say both are about fair, though the first is a little underpay. I’d go with the second one if you must, but the sorbet could definitely go for higher.

please don't give false advise? The first trade isn't "about fair".
the sorbet is worth two green toxics, their side is only worth just over 1 for the first trade.

there's a gap of around 7-8 mid-advents between their side and the sorbet. it's the better trade imo. It's up to if you're fine with losing that much value for the quantity trade-down.

[♡ʜᴏɴᴇʏ♡]

hello! i was wondering this is fair. id really like to get a reply, ive been reposting this for over 10 pages and still haven't gotten one yet. thank you =) <3

[dinolover519]

1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=78689262&userid=506060&signature=4bS7zmZfJ19AvqiyKyFEFg

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=78694808&userid=506060&signature=iqMXzH5HMtuYQ4ggyZmZbQ

Should I take either of these??

I’d say both are about fair, though the first is a little underpay. I’d go with the second one if you must, but the sorbet could definitely go for higher.

please don't give false advise? The first trade isn't "about fair".
the sorbet is worth two green toxics, their side is only worth just over 1 for the first trade.

there's a gap of around 7-8 mid-advents between their side and the sorbet. it's the better trade imo. It's up to if you're fine with losing that much value for the quantity trade-down.

I didn’t say it was fair, and I recommended against taking it, saying the sorbet has a much higher demand, and if they had to take one, to take the second one. That being said, my words were a bit ambiguous and I apologize if you misunderstood. I should have elaborated more.

is this fair?

No, I wouldn’t deem it very fair. However, if you prefer bulk pets compared to rarer pets, take it. Else, I wouldn’t recommend it. Especially when if you really want bulk, you can auction off that 2013 rare for a lot of commons, for equal or even more than what they’re offering. It also really depends on how you value rares to commons, something everyone values differently.

I’ve been trying to type a response to this trade for a while, but I kept having to recount the bulk pets, sorry for not getting to you sooner.

[opalineteardrops]

hello! i was wondering this is fair. id really like to get a reply, ive been reposting this for over 10 pages and still haven't gotten one yet. thank you =) <3

This trade and whether or not it's fair depends on your rarity math.
Personally, I don't do rarity math (rarity math is, for example, 3 uncommons = 1 rare) so I personally would not take it.
There's also a significant gap in the release dates between their oldest, and your oldest pet, and the age of one of your rares to consider factoring in ('13 rare)

I think the reason you havent gotten an answer is because this isnt a clear cut trade and depends quite a bit on how you personally value your pets, and what form of rarity math you subscribe to.

If it were me?
I wouldn't take it.
I think, with more patience, you could get a better deal.

[NULL VOID]

Um hi friends, I need a little help with this Bid, I'm not very good with items or CS, and I'm a little nervous about going so far down the Mains list with this bid. But its the best one I've gotten so far and would LOVE some help with how fair it is.

BID HERE

I personally would not take it because c$ is very hard to then trade back for list pets again.

That makes sense and I have observed that in other Auctions. Thank you for reasponding! Could I get at least one more opinion please?

[Flawless.]

Is this fair?
Thank you in advance .

[Evils]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78718884&userid=310957&signature=FUdc0QupXkWgNPSowGt1og

What would I need to add to make this fair? I know the bat is from '10!

[♡ʜᴏɴᴇʏ♡]

is this fair?

No, I wouldn’t deem it very fair. However, if you prefer bulk pets compared to rarer pets, take it. Else, I wouldn’t recommend it. Especially when if you really want bulk, you can auction off that 2013 rare for a lot of commons, for equal or even more than what they’re offering. It also really depends on how you value rares to commons, something everyone values differently.

I’ve been trying to type a response to this trade for a while, but I kept having to recount the bulk pets, sorry for not getting to you sooner.

Thank you so much. That really helps.

hello! i was wondering this is fair. id really like to get a reply, ive been reposting this for over 10 pages and still haven't gotten one yet. thank you =) <3

This trade and whether or not it's fair depends on your rarity math.
Personally, I don't do rarity math (rarity math is, for example, 3 uncommons = 1 rare) so I personally would not take it.
There's also a significant gap in the release dates between their oldest, and your oldest pet, and the age of one of your rares to consider factoring in ('13 rare)

I think the reason you havent gotten an answer is because this isnt a clear cut trade and depends quite a bit on how you personally value your pets, and what form of rarity math you subscribe to.

If it were me?
I wouldn't take it.
I think, with more patience, you could get a better deal.

Alright, thanks so much for your help.