The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GhostPants]

Alright, I have these three trades.
The one with the dragon egg claims it is the white malk dragon, but i really dont want to be fooled out of my pets. [they said i could wait but if it IS the white malk, is the trade fair?] White malk trade

And this one, im not fond of the black and white target litter, i just dont find them appealing and when i had the target dog i had to trade for underpay.. Target Dog trade

Another one, its fair rarity wise but i think i could maybe get more for it due to demand, Thoughts? Purple Sleipnir

Would any of you accept demand wise? Im not sure how much the Purple Sleipnir is and i keep getting trades for him or with him in it.. so he must have atleast good demand? Thank you for any responses! i appreciate any and all!!

- Gasoline

[MozartStarling]

Suggestions to make this trade more fair or overpay on my part, please?

[Ford Fusion]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78707144&userid=755026&signature=_11fZ6C-oylOwhS0bUKHew

I'm wondering if this is fair?

[Cottonpaw]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78706851&userid=437421&signature=U0vL5fnbwtnxBBWvQjJjHg
Hey all! Is this fair? I think it's a bit unfair to me (bottom) but I dunno. If it is unfair does anyone have any advice on what to remove/add?

This is unfair to you. 4 of their 2011 uncommons equal your 2 2010 uncommons. Then the one 2011 uncommon left i fair for your 2013 rare. Everything else should be taken away from your side.

[emburs]

Wondering if this is fair
ʅ(°⊱,°)ʃ

[Corey Taylor]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78698739&userid=781126&signature=xjEZy4ETKGHO9SnXXmg-XQ

Is this fair?

[clarke,]

which offer is worth more?

bid one
bid two
bid three

i am aware these are all overpay for the lions - but based on demand, which is the fairest?

[bee.kind]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78707144&userid=755026&signature=_11fZ6C-oylOwhS0bUKHew

I'm wondering if this is fair?

rarity wise the ur tiger is worth 5 nons but can go for more with demand.
their side is a non-swirl + ceg (non with demand) + ur foal (currently worth 1.5 sorbs but is supposed to be moved up to ur lion tier ~1 non + green tox) + ur malk (1 non) + line tribal (not really that effective)

(I don't really consider pets like the cake dogs in this trade because they don't really affect the overall value with pets this valuable)

overall I'd say its unfair to you because their side is only worth about 4 nons and a little less than a sorb (and thats if you value the foal at a non because its supposed to move up). the tiger has good demand so you should be able to fetch more c:

[Ford Fusion]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78707144&userid=755026&signature=_11fZ6C-oylOwhS0bUKHew

I'm wondering if this is fair?

rarity wise the ur tiger is worth 5 nons but can go for more with demand.
their side is a non-swirl + ceg (non with demand) + ur foal (currently worth 1.5 sorbs but is supposed to be moved up to ur lion tier ~1 non + green tox) + ur malk (1 non) + line tribal (not really that effective)

(I don't really consider pets like the cake dogs in this trade because they don't really affect the overall value with pets this valuable)

overall I'd say its unfair to you because their side is only worth about 4 nons and a little less than a sorb (and thats if you value the foal at a non because its supposed to move up). the tiger has good demand so you should be able to fetch more c:

Thank you!

[weld]

i need help on this