The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[firebirdspeedy]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78608696&userid=209952&signature=IARf8VZMSt6F7oteQ58www

[Heck.]

So I’m hosting two auctions right now and I wanna see which bids are fair (btw, I value the BMD a little over a sorbet) Also, these trade all are about demand, not just rarity

BMD:
1 - How fair is this? I mainly don’t like the C$ but I’d still like to know how fair it is :)

2 - This one is my favorite, but is it fair? A lot of tribals don’t have great demand and same for the cake dogs, so I’m still wondering

-3 - I think that this one isn’t fair, but this is just to double check

-4 - This too

-5 - I also think this is unfair, but what is the white Malk dragon going for?

250 C$:
1 - I’m really confused on this one, is it fair or under? (Demand wise as well)

2 - I know that this is technically fair, but how’s the demand for that rat? How low would I have to go to get something or would I just be able to do a tier swap?
Guys I’ve been trying for a while :([

[Ironic Equation]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78606503&userid=927208&signature=fkkn_zrwjy_iDuYd7cU0yQ

please help ive been trying for hours

It's unfair to you. The peppermint bun is a list pet worth 4-5 mixed '09 rares and an '09 uncommon, while they are only offering two and a recent rare, as well as asking for all those newborns.

[Spooky~]

Since my nick finally grew...

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78594043&userid=763673&signature=IfY91A6qiFHbLTfPc9gTOA

[Horror]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78606503&userid=927208&signature=fkkn_zrwjy_iDuYd7cU0yQ

please help ive been trying for hours

your bun = 4-5 09 rares + 09 uc
their vr bun = 2 09 rares since it's not a list, and their recent rare can be ignored

unfair to you

so i’m running an auction and i plan on running all my bids through here for help on ranking them. i just received my first bid so could someone tell me how fair it is? x

and this one. x

please, i’ve been trying for hours. i’m not good with c$ and lots of pets

The 2 trades are the same

here’s the real second bid. now could someone help me? please and thank you?

1. their side is worth a mid sept or about 1/3 of the tess horse
2. tess horse is worth 465c$ making this a bit unfair to you

[drown]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78611398&userid=804583&signature=MHLShhybQk3Lfqed6XHmwA
This is fair, right? I'm not looking for trade downs but this cat is kind of hard to trade.

Please? Been trying for a bit.

[BlankRedColor]

Which one is better? Demand and rarity

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78603293&userid=182352&signature=lHwhEyQLfCgCDnnxuIoUTw

Or

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78602913&userid=182352&signature=NMYOLkrKZUQkmFVNa2jPvQ


Also what could make this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78611495&userid=182352&signature=LnICElISDmf2bpTJJNp7wg

[/quote][/quote]

[cavetowns]

purple toxic for a shima longtail, would that be fair? i know that rarity wise the purple toxic is worth more than the shima longtail, but i know that the shima longtail has amazing demand (since last time i checked, i'm not sure if it changed since then) and i don't think the purple toxic has great demand, considering i've never gotten a fair trade for it, and i never find anybody looking for it (unless it's their dreamie). so, should i take the trade? i have a feeling i could get way more from the shima than i could ever get for the toxic. some help would be greatly appreciated, as i'm really unsure of what to do. once again, i'm not really taking rarity into consideration right now, mostly demand, and what each pet usually goes for.

please help

[Rulersrule]

I'm holding an auction and was wondering how fair these bids were. Thank you for any help <3
1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6

Could I please have some help..? I've been trying for awhile.

[skip]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78605004&userid=929954&signature=_4cuJbS4-nSMOBAur6q1rw
I'm wondering if this is fair, if not, what should be added?

Anyone? I've been trying for several hours