The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Targaryen]

Can someone help me with these 3?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78441479&userid=784303&signature=DTzHUlmPj8WhNKH_fNgl1w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78439427&userid=784303&signature=EyoayAx8LrwdjgycuY-7vA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78438174&userid=784303&signature=seiPEF4iNjGADhZP3Sdw6A

1. I count around 6 nons val, if not just under slightly guesstimating. The orange cerb can get just under that alone, I wouldn't take it. ^^ A lot of the pets also aren't of best demand. 7/10 bid?

2. Advent quantity is very highly sought after but I think most people don't value 10-15 mid-advents above 1 non. ^^ Id say that's slightly underpay for the red cerb alone. 6/10 maybe because the mid-advent quantity is really nice but not the best value c:

3. Also guesstimating around 6-7 nons value valuing the rat at 1 non? The tribals have fairly poor demand so it's not the best but the value is quite good. 7.5/10 maybe c:

I hope that helps, that's just my personal opinion at a glance ^^

[UnworthyElevator]

Alright i've asked a lot today but ive gotten one last offer - its 14 pets btw. This is the offer

[LionKingdom]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78441015&userid=925400&signature=KpJ86XyrHfPWrHu190K9vw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78436303&userid=925400&signature=Zg1m47Ijlv2GZ01rJT9EKQ

Which bid is the best?

[Targaryen]

Alright i've asked a lot today but ive gotten one last offer - its 14 pets btw. This is the offer

Just about fair if not a tiny bit over on your side. I wouldn't personally as i value quantity highly vs. their tree advent's less-good demand but it's not a bad trade overall. c:

[xietys]

Opinion on these 2? Are they okay?

click

click

[moon child]

Should I accept this? How many nons is the ur cat side trades/viewtrade.php?id=78440785&userid=774839&signature=-L56qYZLcb6zGbuDnt0dsQ

[- Alice -]

Can someone help me with these 3?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78441479&userid=784303&signature=DTzHUlmPj8WhNKH_fNgl1w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78439427&userid=784303&signature=EyoayAx8LrwdjgycuY-7vA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78438174&userid=784303&signature=seiPEF4iNjGADhZP3Sdw6A

1. I count around 6 nons val, if not just under slightly guesstimating. The orange cerb can get just under that alone, I wouldn't take it. ^^ A lot of the pets also aren't of best demand. 7/10 bid?

2. Advent quantity is very highly sought after but I think most people don't value 10-15 mid-advents above 1 non. ^^ Id say that's slightly underpay for the red cerb alone. 6/10 maybe because the mid-advent quantity is really nice but not the best value c:

3. Also guesstimating around 6-7 nons value valuing the rat at 1 non? The tribals have fairly poor demand so it's not the best but the value is quite good. 7.5/10 maybe c:

I hope that helps, that's just my personal opinion at a glance ^^

Thank you so much for your help! You couldn't help me again could you? I just got these two ;3; I already have a sunjewel tho and overal I'm trying to get list quantity xD would the ur tiger be the way to go?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=78441866&userid=784303&signature=k7bh6n7wiKo4msWCn9IJ0w (they edited it to that!)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78441784&userid=784303&signature=5fLilZ7etcL3_yq7TKNQmw

[xietys]

Opinion on these 2? Are they okay?

click

click

[LionKingdom]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78441015&userid=925400&signature=KpJ86XyrHfPWrHu190K9vw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78436303&userid=925400&signature=Zg1m47Ijlv2GZ01rJT9EKQ

Which bid is the best?

[Kazunan]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78440691&userid=907285&signature=T8L9dE0wlHNNUJSZheEjrw

Should I take this? I really like the alien dog but I’m not sure what it’s worth.