The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[seti]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78430508&userid=764129&signature=uIOxkIxDLJEz04RljQgG4w

how’s this???

[swiftheart54]

How is this demand wise? not sure what the dragon will be yet but dang...
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78429943&userid=351237&signature=1FHXeXpnn9patYAIWKZZ6w

[Evils]

There are 610 Pets on my side. I was just wondering if this trade would be worth it since it's taking a majority of my trade fodder.
I'm really tempted but would like some opinions of others who have been actively trading list pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78429414&userid=26479&signature=EuDu4vpACM2RVSn0YCdQ5g

I haven't actively traded for list pets in awhile, but I can confidently say that they are asking for a lot of overpay on your side. While the orange Cerberus is in a good demand among those seeking it, it is not worth that many rares and very rares, especially since most of them seem to be coming from '09 and '10 with a few from '08.
I think they may be trying to play it as you getting a good deal from it when you're really not, as they aren't asking for list pets. You could get a lot more for your pets than just an orange cerberus. I'd take a few more opinions as I've been away from the list trading game for awhile, but I do know that in calculating a C$ price comparison (this may not be accurate since comparing pets to C$ isn't always equal to value of the pet in pets), you would be overpaying by more than 5x, maybe even 6x, for sure as the Orange Cerberus is valued 505 C$ while an 09 rare could go for 30 c$ at best.
I know that a mid advent is valued at around 7 09' rares, but I'm just unsure how many an orange cerberus would add up to.

[Redbud]

how would my side be for their single gearback? and is the gearback easy to trade off?

[KookieKrumblez]

Auctioning a Balloon Dog, and I got these two bids so far. Which is better, and which one can get me a BMD? Also, on a scale of 1-10 how would you rate these?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78429748&userid=937646&signature=p88mTBogoYR_43Af1FNzMQ #1
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78430015&userid=937646&signature=h_xhz2wgenrQZVP41wIxwQ #2

Help Please? <3

[Targaryen]

There are 610 Pets on my side. I was just wondering if this trade would be worth it since it's taking a majority of my trade fodder.
I'm really tempted but would like some opinions of others who have been actively trading list pets.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78429414&userid=26479&signature=EuDu4vpACM2RVSn0YCdQ5g

Rarity wise, an Orange Cerberus is only worth a Balloon Dog - 21 mid advents - or around 150 09 rares. You're overpaying rarity wise by 3-4x it's value.

However - Orange Cerberuses tend to go for 4-5 nons regardless of list placement. This is the equivalent of over 1,000 advents or 7,000 09 rares.
That means... your side is technically underpay - demand wise.
However, I would note that quantity goes for extreme overpay a lot of the time.


Would I personally take it? Absolutely not. You're trading an extortionate amount of quantity which is insanely hard to come by, nevermind trade for. Cerberuses aren't too hard to trade for with a little bit of quantity quality lists and patience. I think you could get a better offer. That's just my personal opinion - mostly because I value quantity extraordinarily high.

[Targaryen]

[
Second opinion please?

agree. you can do better.

[justina valentine]

Hello!
Okay so I would like some opinions on this.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78425904&userid=769336&signature=b5XaTrjfToDbRC7D_eSFiw

+ some chicken dollars (their limit is 500)

I know this is unfair but I said I don't mind underpay if their is quantity c:



Got one opinion would like some more c:

Please <3

[Nicnova]

Is this trade fair?

I'm not much of an item person, I'm afraid

[Targaryen]

Hello!
Okay so I would like some opinions on this.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78425904&userid=769336&signature=b5XaTrjfToDbRC7D_eSFiw

+ some chicken dollars (their limit is 500)

I know this is unfair but I said I don't mind underpay if their is quantity c:



Got one opinion would like some more c:

Please <3

Even with the quantity, I still wouldn't do it - the quantity isn't even of "popular" or particularly "in demand" advents. I think you would be better off trading down for main-lists and then advents - you'll keep more value that way (: