The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[✦ nemuri]

i know nothing about list trading so! time to get some help. is this fair? i might not accept it because i do have a level of attachment/sentiment towards some of the pets because they were gifts, but i’m curious to learn in order to re enter the trading game wkfnmsnfmskfk

also need help with this trade! ^^;;

1. personally i wouldn’t just because I hate trading up
2. it’s fair but i wouldn’t because i prefer to stay on the list

aa thank you ! may i get a second opinion on the first trade? ;w;

edit; oops this trade came in as well. i read somewhere that a 2015 store pet was worth a 2010 rare, so what’s the rate for a 2014 store pet? how much rarer is a 2009 rare compared to a 2010 rare?

[Banana.]

Is this fair?
I think I prefer my balloon anyway I’m just curious
x

[wanderlust,]

this trade is pretty difficult for me to figure out, i dont know how much the BMD is worth and the card dog could either turn into a joker or not. my sunpup could either turn into a non or a sunjewel. is this trade fair for either a non or a sunjewel, taking into account the card dog may or may not be a joker? thank you so much
xxx

[plutone]

I'm auctioning off my ur zonkey, and these are the best four bids I've got
I'm leaning towards the one with the ur bwolf but I'd like some other opinions
Some of the bids are higher value on the list, but I'm not too good with knowing the general demand

yellow android + ur bwolf

red rose dog + plains zebra + 100cs$

t7 advent + ur strawberry + t2 advent

t1 advent + t2 advent + t6 advent + 1800cs$

[This Is Halloween]

fair? including demand please

Very unfair to them, the demand for the lion is very high though. It's been fetching main lists regularly

Thank you! Second opinions? What's the cake dogs worth?[/quote]

[LionKingdom]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78417389&userid=925400&signature=F5fn0-1rFTu5Ru7Aj7vVMw

Is this fair? If not what can they add?

[wanderlust,]

this trade is pretty difficult for me to figure out, i dont know how much the BMD is worth and the card dog could either turn into a joker or not. my sunpup could either turn into a non or a sunjewel. is this trade fair for either a non or a sunjewel, taking into account the card dog may or may not be a joker? thank you so much
xxx

[chihirofujisaki]

this trade is pretty difficult for me to figure out, i dont know how much the BMD is worth and the card dog could either turn into a joker or not. my sunpup could either turn into a non or a sunjewel. is this trade fair for either a non or a sunjewel, taking into account the card dog may or may not be a joker? thank you so much
xxx

Scenario one: If the card dog is not a joker and your pup becomes a non, it's unfair to you.

Scenario two: If the card dog is a joker and your pup becomes a non, it's unfair to them.

Scenario three: Regardless of what the card dog is, if your pup is a sunjewel, it's unfair to you.

I think the BMD goes for about a balloon dog, but overall it doesn't have a big effect on this trade. The only thing it changes is if scenario 2 occurs, then a fair trade becomes overpay on their part.

I wouldn't take this. There's a two in three chance that it'll become very unfair to you.

I hope this helped!

Also: How does this look?

[✦ nemuri]

i know nothing about list trading so! time to get some help. is this fair? i might not accept it because i do have a level of attachment/sentiment towards some of the pets because they were gifts, but i’m curious to learn in order to re enter the trading game wkfnmsnfmskfk

also need help with this trade! ^^;;

1. personally i wouldn’t just because I hate trading up
2. it’s fair but i wouldn’t because i prefer to stay on the list

aa thank you ! may i get a second opinion on the first trade? ;w;

edit; oops this trade came in as well. i read somewhere that a 2015 store pet was worth a 2010 rare, so what’s the rate for a 2014 store pet? how much rarer is a 2009 rare compared to a 2010 rare?

[Banana.]

Is this fair?
I think I prefer my balloon anyway I’m just curious
x