The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[cup of cocoa]

Is this trade fair? If not, how much C$ would be needed to make it fair?

[Syn_cat]

Hello, is this trade fair?

[miyoni]

thank you in advance for the help !
x

[✦ nemuri]

i know nothing about list trading so! time to get some help. is this fair? i might not accept it because i do have a level of attachment/sentiment towards some of the pets because they were gifts, but i’m curious to learn in order to re enter the trading game wkfnmsnfmskfk

also need help with this trade! ^^;;

1. personally i wouldn’t just because I hate trading up
2. it’s fair but i wouldn’t because i prefer to stay on the list

aa thank you ! may i get a second opinion on the first trade? ;w;

edit; oops this trade came in as well. i read somewhere that a 2015 store pet was worth a 2010 rare, so what’s the rate for a 2014 store pet? how much rarer is a 2009 rare compared to a 2010 rare?

[Sardonyx]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78406982&userid=785388&signature=C8Ao5lG8wBMh_B2x4vUr9A Is this trade fair? If not what needs to be changed?

[Sebassy]

Fair? Demand wise?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78404073&userid=941852&signature=k0Kr3iuo4lyMBimBGcwJEQ


Help!

[brownponygypsy]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78405169&userid=378579&signature=TApOh6apyxWyB7ExuBA5oQ
For my I do not think so but I would like some help please

[bre <3]

Is this trade fair? If not, how much C$ would be needed to make it fair?

i wouldn’t accept this. i’m not that great at determining the worth of c$ (because it honestly depends on how much you personally value it, and whether or not you are able to easily purchase it). but, i would never accept this myself, it’s a horrible deal in my opinion.

[Looperslair]

Hello, is this trade fair?

Demand wise the bmd usually goes for at least balloon dog to a sorbet at most. It really depends on how you value the pet.

So, no this is not fair to the bmd.

[Ironic Equation]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78405979&userid=369442&signature=coTq_t2USkgp3kU-QdNvUw
They've edited, would you personally do this?

By the way, I'd always advise anyone asking on this thread to get a second opinion as people value things differently and I've seen some false advice while going through it.