The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[depressedanonymous,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78131811&userid=952786&signature=Ya8PhGPc0ibaSH3vkK3mag do you think this was a fair trade?

That was EXTREMELY unfair to you. Your pet is on the main list while their pets don’t even value an 09 rare

[madteas]

could i get anymore opinions on this trade before i accept?

[kunikida]

Whoops, back again already;;

x --- I'm very tempted by this,
could someone let me know if I am overpaying?
Thanks x

This seems fair. The Lion is worth 2 - 3 ‘09 Rares, so their side might be overpaying a bit. It seems fair for the most part, though.

Many thanks <3

[aloe.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78396996&userid=869763&signature=YjukrhbHUuOaWMYeJ7lBWQ
Looking for help with this trade! The UR dog is my biggest dreamie but I’m not sure if this is fair or not?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78399319&userid=869763&signature=5uwaLY6HskBFSdRa2NPYiQ
Also this trade? Not too fond but I’m not sure :3

Second trade, you'd be getting an over.

Thank you! :3
possible second opinion? :,o

First trade is incredibly unfair to you, second is slight overpay on their side because coontails are very high on the main list. (The toxic pup and a few of the others are lists though, so it depends whether you would prefer to have multiple lesser list pets or one high list)

[cup of cocoa]

Is this trade fair? If not, how much C$ would be needed to make it fair?

[✦ nemuri]

i know nothing about list trading so! time to get some help. is this fair? i might not accept it because i do have a level of attachment/sentiment towards some of the pets because they were gifts, but i’m curious to learn in order to re enter the trading game wkfnmsnfmskfk

also need help with this trade! ^^;;

[aloe.]

UR Lion for July PPS with demand? I don’t think I’ve ever had the Ur Lion.

July PPS is higher in demand than the lion.

[boston]

UR Lion for July PPS with demand? I don’t think I’ve ever had the Ur Lion.

July PPS is higher in demand than the lion.

i see the pps going for 1 non, if that.
i personally find it easier to trade off the lion than the pps.

[Plague Rot]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=59239017&userid=831658&signature=TTZwgDE7O59Ch5dLC3ewXA
I got this awhile ago and just started wondering if it was even fair

[depressedanonymous,]

i know nothing about list trading so! time to get some help. is this fair? i might not accept it because i do have a level of attachment/sentiment towards some of the pets because they were gifts, but i’m curious to learn in order to re enter the trading game wkfnmsnfmskfk

also need help with this trade! ^^;;

1. personally i wouldn’t just because I hate trading up
2. it’s fair but i wouldn’t because i prefer to stay on the list