Is this a Fair Trade? (Dec 18th edition)

[dragonwriter]

Would a Green-fronted Holly Dog from December 18th 2009 be a fair trade for a White Rainbow-Stripe dog from January 2009?

[ozzi9816]

The person in question says he's accepting paperclip offers for this pet. Would a 2009 VR be a better choice (assuming its also paperclip)? I can also add another litter or two of store pets

[ozzi9816]

Update: trades/viewtrade.php?id=79616593&userid=330581&signature=S8s7j5ABGKjSOHoerkrDpg
we reached this point in negotiations

[acura,]

Update: trades/viewtrade.php?id=79616593&userid=330581&signature=S8s7j5ABGKjSOHoerkrDpg
we reached this point in negotiations

Personally ,, I wouldn’t accept this trade.

The store corgis are in high demand and go for quite a bit depending on who you trade with. I’ve seen the corgi set itself go for multiple advents - low September list pets ,, just a few examples here ;;
x x
x

but you’re free to decide ! don’t take my opinion to heart, as it’s just my opinion !

[ozzi9816]

Would that existing trade be fine if it was just the VR advent dog and only the rainbow corgi? Or does not having the whole set diminish its value?

[ozzi9816]

also this one? (it's an auction and I'm the first bidder, just wanna make sure I'm not bidding too high)

[Spinda]

So yikes... I'm new and this is my first huuuuge trade. I sincerely need help please. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79622691&userid=958822&signature=fNP2Ax

[acura,]

also this one? (it's an auction and I'm the first bidder, just wanna make sure I'm not bidding too high)

Extremely unfair to the other person. Your bid does not even equal a high-advent list pet, let alone a dog tag up on the main list.

[Spinda]

So yikes... I'm new and this is my first huuuuge trade. I sincerely need help please. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79622691&userid=958822&signature=fNP2Axwdx_ZyOOIKHkzgbQ

Edit::

I also have this trade. It looks to me that this asian dragon dog is a huge hit

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79624427&userid=958822&signature=NkDK3619TSE-KfyJfgE4VA

[lucky333123]

So yikes... I'm new and this is my first huuuuge trade. I sincerely need help please. Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79622691&userid=958822&signature=fNP2Axwdx_ZyOOIKHkzgbQ

Edit::

I also have this trade. It looks to me that this asian dragon dog is a huge hit

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79624427&userid=958822&signature=NkDK3619TSE-KfyJfgE4VA

Hello,

The first trade is unfair to the top by a fair amount. All the '11 uncommons alone are overpay for your side.

The second trade is also unfair to the top. The rare alone is overpay because even if the dragon dog turns rare, the rare on their side is still worth slightly more.