The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eeveeloverrr]

Could someone tell me if these are fair??
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78312036&userid=697000&signature=UqhZyoSnbUqKDgH-1qHelA

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78309669&userid=697000&signature=5dXZXCEp8FxJx5W0TF6TyA

And which one is better?

both are unfair to you, they're underpaying with a lot considering demand

Thank you so much!

[mikae]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78302020&userid=756356&signature=MFGNTpKEipwMFTNqn0EBrw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78312349&userid=756356&signature=AZ-00BsGwOHG0UdsWCygaw
are either of these fair?

does anyone know? i've been asking for an hour oof

[September Rain]

Which of these is best?

[greensmurf]

This trade

and

This trade

Thanks in advance

The first one is more fair. The second doesn't add up to the value of your cat which is a list. Get a second opinion

Thank you for your help
Since it was suggested, I’m looking for a second opinion on these. Thanks!

[n e w s i e s]

Hello! I got https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78314340&userid=794585&signature=wMmnMrcNOlMXYqIof91QVg this trade for a bunch of pets that I'm not terribly interested in trading away, but the person offered a Toxic. I don't know about the demand on Toxics so I guess what I'm trying to ask is... is this trade fair?

[Targaryen]

opinions?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78310388&userid=698931&signature=ZrM1kWnhAQMgKlA7A1D7YA would

1.
2
3
4
5. or replace sorb+balloon with TD BMD
6.
7

advice with experience in both rarity and common demand values only please <3

[bertholdt]

Warning- Trades are kinda big

Which one of these offers for the sept list has higher value (ignore whether its fair or not)

this or this?

Thank you in advance and happy holidays! <3

[dxmxnxc]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78302020&userid=756356&signature=MFGNTpKEipwMFTNqn0EBrw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78312349&userid=756356&signature=AZ-00BsGwOHG0UdsWCygaw
are either of these fair?

does anyone know? i've been asking for an hour oof

first one over on their side i believe, second one is all up to whether you like the zebra or not, zebras don’t have that good of demand but generally speaking, the zebra trade is an over trade.
personally, i’d take the UR BWolf bc it’s worth around 3 nons + a purple toxic & the zebra is 3 nons & a blue toxic.

[catnip.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78316278&userid=735399&signature=korb3DwJOKQGDqAIzHsHOg
is this fair?

[Targaryen]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78302020&userid=756356&signature=MFGNTpKEipwMFTNqn0EBrw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78312349&userid=756356&signature=AZ-00BsGwOHG0UdsWCygaw
are either of these fair?

first one over on their side i believe, second one is all up to whether you like the zebra or not, zebras don’t have that good of demand but generally speaking, the zebra trade is an over trade.
personally, i’d take the UR BWolf bc it’s worth around 3 nons + a purple toxic & the zebra is 3 nons & a blue toxic.

I disagree - I wouldn't take either because the zebra and ur bwolf only get around 1-1.5 nons due to poor demand whereas the Bee generally gets list placement value if not over ^^