The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sumatra.]

Is this Fair?
If it helps I typically use the 2:1 ratio

[the]

Is this Fair?
If it helps I typically use the 2:1 ratio

Using 2:1 ratio:
Uncommon '14 = rare '15 = 2 rares '16 = 4 rares '17 = 8 rares '18, so that's fair.

[Ari!]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77808181&userid=371792&signature=yhlq47gBSoG5XPSxYV_7Vg
is this fair?

[protect]

x
is this fair under or over? and if so by how much

[Ucanthandleme]

Is this fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77819020&userid=809102&signature=M4tSMMNi-2hsTiJBxtl9fA

[lady gaga]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77808181&userid=371792&signature=yhlq47gBSoG5XPSxYV_7Vg
is this fair?

unfair to you, your store pet is worth a mid-late '10 rare.

[KittyandCat]

Is this fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77818960&userid=945930&signature=8N2Aw2viOIXvghzgAPN7fQ

[deleted prince]

Hi there, I'd really appreciate some help with these: I'm not overly happy with the pets, but I'm very confused about how fair they are.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77809252&userid=715407&signature=wBR5ZpPtnu3cstggyhv35w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77809228&userid=715407&signature=Fxu6DQwHXWAKV9bYdEI_zA

[sumatra.]

Is this fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77819020&userid=809102&signature=M4tSMMNi-2hsTiJBxtl9fA

Unfair to you.
Their dog is worth a 2009 rare.
Just one of the rates on your side would be fair for it

Hi there, I'd really appreciate some help with these: I'm not overly happy with the pets, but I'm very confused about how fair they are.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77809252&userid=715407&signature=wBR5ZpPtnu3cstggyhv35w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77809228&userid=715407&signature=Fxu6DQwHXWAKV9bYdEI_zA

The second trade is very unfair to you.
95 C$ is worth a tier 9 advent list
Their side is only worth a bit over a 2010 rare

[the]

The second trade is very unfair to you.
95 C$ is worth a tier 9 advent list
Their side is only worth a bit over a 2010 rare

I disagree in the second trade.

When paying for multiple pets, always convert all the pets to C$ individually, and then add it up, no matter if it's a list pet or a normal value.
If you're paying for 2 09 rares (say 2 mid 09s) you have to pay 70C$ (35C$+35C$). You can't add up the pets first and then convert to C$.

Store pet '17 = 25-30C$
Store pet '18 = 20-25C$
Rare '17 = 2-4C$
Rare '18 = 1-3C$
There are 6 rares '17 and 11 rares '18.
Total top worth: 68-112C$