The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[fallen;]

Between these two trades, which is the best option for trading my peas? Thank you in advance for whoever can help ^u^

one
two

[Targaryen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248130&userid=735229&signature=-4Sdi15G8gQrvCe2Jv2arA

any opinions would be much appreciated.

I wouldn't take it, it isn't hard to get trades upwards of a non-dog for the new UR Cat.

Note though, it doesn't have an actual value yet due to being released only two-three days ago.

thank you so much. do you know if this is any better?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248570&userid=735229&signature=VPH6ISOky-J_aWiBlDjg_Q

non truedate BAs tend to go for around 1-2 sorbets, the quantity may make up for that depending on how you value quantity?
Id personally pass.
I highly suggest hosting a quick auction to get an influx of bids to compare in value. Demand for new URS is a tricky thing because it's so inconsistent. You'll definitely see if you can get more that way and find what people are willing to trade to date.

[Chico_Mistpool]

what do I have to add/remove

[drown]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248282&userid=804583&signature=BU6C0X4FC_5w241etYhTGw
Would this be fair? Don't know what the growing pet is/worth

[WeirdWhiteStarDoggo]

Between these two trades, which is the best option for trading my peas?

one
two

the purple toxic is (3 tiers above) greater than the sorbet by 2 balloon dogs + a red x pps
i don't know if the value of the other pets in the second offer with the sorbet is worth that?
the peas don't have a set value with so whatever you're comfortable with/like more?
personally if those were my peas i'd take the toxic just because i dont like the peas

[Frankina]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248257&userid=747307&signature=ev1LFH0AcK9BQDN2ftPglA
been offered this, what do BEGs usually go for and do they have decent demand? thank you in advance

edit: i’ve been send this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248522&userid=747307&signature=esR3jOXllnXY_2ccYxiFyQ
which they said the BW is worth 3 nons. Is it hard to trade off and would you recommend i take it for my strawb?

thanks vexious and targaryen!
posting again as i’ve edited it with another trade c:

The BEG is a solid offer, though the UR BW is significantly better in my view.
You’d be getting a lot more value in terms of rarity and I wouldn’t say the BW
is impossible to trade off. You just need a little patience to find someone who likes
the species and is willing to offer you a fair deal. It’s worth 3x the arbitrary going value
of the new strawberry and I doubt the strawberry would be placed that high over the gap anyways.
Overall, I’d take the UR BW offer but ultimately it’s up to you :]

[Horror]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248462&userid=844777&signature=rLmnbDSPKtswEzhTI4uOwA

Is this fair? I also heard that some 09 VR pets are going to be put on the list, but I'm not sure. Thank you in advance!

as far as I know the only 09 vr that's currently in line to be discussed for a possible placement is the 09 vr cream/white rabbit
making this unfair to them as even valuing their dogs both at the least valuable outcome, their side is worth about 3.5 09 rares minimum

[madteas]

Im being flooded, and feeling very overwhelmed.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248650&userid=735229&signature=fnnW3oiDOeboc5qWWsOxAg
this will be my last post, but this has a non coon or coon dog pup. does that make it better?

[chaozdackel]

I really do want the phoenix but i know the Zonkey is one tier higher.
Is the below gap pet worth it? or would a UR bengal (or fennec) and phoenix be better for the zonkey?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78211960&userid=631491&signature=ha2EN45CBg1xr8uP4xb_lA

Or would this be better?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78234787&userid=631491&signature=IYm8y2sWA8EZ8LIU21ohtw

[Targaryen]

Im being flooded, and feeling very overwhelmed.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248650&userid=735229&signature=fnnW3oiDOeboc5qWWsOxAg
this will be my last post, but this has a non coon or coon dog pup. does that make it better?

The least that coon pup could be is a noncoon - which is a big step up from your other trades - on top of that a gearback tribal! It's a fairly nice trade. It's up to you if you want that.

Again, Id suggest running an auction to see the full range of offers ^^