The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Kazunan]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248454&userid=907285&signature=O9JnKvDNBq6Vg-SgRu9Eqg

Is this fair? If not what do I need to add, thank you to who replies!

unfair to the cat as it is going to be placed somewhere on the mainlist, and I believe I see one list on your side?

There’s a tier seven September list and a tier seven advent list on my side, I’ll see if they edit it to be more fair to them. Thanks for the help <3

[fallen;]

Between these two trades, which is the best option for trading my peas? Thank you in advance for whoever can help ^u^

one
two

[hayzel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248257&userid=747307&signature=ev1LFH0AcK9BQDN2ftPglA
been offered this, what do BEGs usually go for and do they have decent demand? thank you in advance

edit: i’ve been send this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248522&userid=747307&signature=esR3jOXllnXY_2ccYxiFyQ
which they said the BW is worth 3 nons. Is it hard to trade off and would you recommend i take it for my strawb?

thanks vexious and targaryen!
posting again as i’ve edited it with another trade c:

[drown]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248282&userid=804583&signature=BU6C0X4FC_5w241etYhTGw
Would this be fair? Don't know what the growing pet is/worth

[Chico_Mistpool]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248431&userid=811231&signature=cbnA-8iU1RsxQPEeoOHPXw

What would I have to add/remove to make this fair for both of us?

[*Nevi Nova*]

is This trade fair? im not good with items

[madteas]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248130&userid=735229&signature=-4Sdi15G8gQrvCe2Jv2arA

any opinions would be much appreciated.

I wouldn't take it, it isn't hard to get trades upwards of a non-dog for the new UR Cat.

Note though, it doesn't have an actual value yet due to being released only two-three days ago.

thank you so much. do you know if this is any better?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248570&userid=735229&signature=VPH6ISOky-J_aWiBlDjg_Q

[Horror]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248130&userid=735229&signature=-4Sdi15G8gQrvCe2Jv2arA

any opinions would be much appreciated.

galaxy cat has no set worth so it's up to you on how you value it
though personally I wouldn't take this as it's unlikely it would be placed that low on the main list as what they're offering

I feel very conflicted about this trade, what are your opinions? (The Jester, lions, and PPS already traded though, so I might resend)
-snip-

(make sure you use the link at the bottom of the trade or cover up the usernames to keep your partner's identity hidden)

2018 rare = 4 2018 uc = 2 2017 uc = 2016 uc (going by the 4:1 uncommon:rare ratio) or a 2015 common
2 2018 rares = 2015 uc / 2014 common

their 2014 common + 2016 uncommon would be enough so it's unfair to them
whether or not you're happy with trading rares for uc/under is up to you

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248454&userid=907285&signature=O9JnKvDNBq6Vg-SgRu9Eqg

Is this fair? If not what do I need to add, thank you to who replies! <3

unfair to the cat as it is going to be placed somewhere on the mainlist, and I believe I see one list on your side?

(cake dog and celestial pps are lists though I agree it's unfair to them still as the side still comes short of any main list)
how much you'd have to add exactly though is up to you and your partner as the galaxy cat is too new to have any set worth or value

[єℓσqυєи¢є]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248462&userid=844777&signature=rLmnbDSPKtswEzhTI4uOwA

Is this fair? I also heard that some 09 VR pets are going to be put on the list, but I'm not sure. Thank you in advance!

[hayzel]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248257&userid=747307&signature=ev1LFH0AcK9BQDN2ftPglA
been offered this, what do BEGs usually go for and do they have decent demand? thank you in advance

edit: i’ve been send this: trades/viewtrade.php?id=78248522&userid=747307&signature=esR3jOXllnXY_2ccYxiFyQ
which they said the BW is worth 3 nons. Is it hard to trade off and would you recommend i take it for my strawb?

thanks vexious and targaryen!
posting again as i’ve edited it with another trade c: which am i better off taking?