The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[awf;l]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78224984&userid=679995&signature=8BwI8ffmO8GCHzaM26NDrg

?

[.wren.]

i'm not too sure of the worth of the ur pineapple,
so i wanted to see if this trade is fair. and this one!
thank you in advance!

both are unfair to you by quite a bit. the pineapple i’ve seen actually has decent demand, but even without that it sits above the gap. the sorbet is better than the other trade, but still the sorbet is a below gap mainlist pet so they would need to add.

[patriciaツ]

their blue toxic for my green sorbet+hyena advent ? here’s the link

i’m very curious about this one, and i’d like to know what the blue toxic goes for as far as it’s demand vs. the sorbet and hyena?
not a huge fan of trade ups, but I don’t want to disappoint someone if I don’t have to :>

sorry if that’s confusing lol thank you for any and all help!

i traded up to a blue sorbet a couple weeks ago with a blue sorbert and a tier 5 advent. the toxic’s demand is not as good as the sorberts however they’re not difficult to trade in my experience. it really depends on how you value the demand, rarity wise a sorbert is 83-84 ma, a blue toxic valued at 94 ma so they are overpaying.

[XxDragonScalesxX]

This?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78212251&userid=765813&signature=75-H_W5z5dIWvEXjLZO49A

[bear]

This?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78212251&userid=765813&signature=75-H_W5z5dIWvEXjLZO49A

Very extremely unfair to you! Your zebra grows up to be on the main advent list and they're only offering 1 advent list pet, which is no where even close to fair at all!

[madteas]

This?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78212251&userid=765813&signature=75-H_W5z5dIWvEXjLZO49A

I believe this is very unfair. the mountain zebra is on the main list above the gap. and none of those are even on the main list. i'd cancel.

[Moonru]

i'm not too sure of the worth of the ur pineapple,
so i wanted to see if this trade is fair. and this one!
thank you in advance!

Unsure about the first of the trades but for the second one it's very unfair to you. The pineapple is an above gap main list while the sorbet is a bit below the gap

i'm not too sure of the worth of the ur pineapple,
so i wanted to see if this trade is fair. and this one!
thank you in advance!

both are unfair to you by quite a bit. the pineapple i’ve seen actually has decent demand, but even without that it sits above the gap. the sorbet is better than the other trade, but still the sorbet is a below gap mainlist pet so they would need to add.

thank you both!

[.wren.]

-snip-

i traded up to a blue sorbet a couple weeks ago with a blue sorbert and a tier 5 advent. the toxic’s demand is not as good as the sorberts however they’re not difficult to trade in my experience. it really depends on how you value the demand, rarity wise a sorbert is 83-84 ma, a blue toxic valued at 94 ma so they are overpaying.

thanks a bunch!

[Inkeyu]

?

Unfair to them, your egg will grow to be a 2015 rare and their 2010 rare alone is overpay.

Hello everyone. Just asking, is this a fair trade? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78199342&userid=151228&signature=ypXokFXMK3ps41Xt9njWGA

Unfair to you due to the age gap.

Thank you.

[Caligasy]

is this fair? I'm bad at this kinds of stuff!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78198462&userid=914019&signature=c0K7Tl0wSS_5c_-MqwlF-g