The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[♥Athena♥]

I keep getting rejected when trying to trade for the last missing horses in my collection

So could anyone tell me if my offers are really unfair?
In my eyes I think i am overpaying, but I am not the best at rarities

This was the last trade getting cancelled
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78072997&userid=673945&signature=EpX_iLRCxyN3mW-Wvag4Kw

So is it me who are wrong or is it just bad luck?
C$ wise it should be worth around 55 and I am offering a lot more in pet value

Rarity wise, you are overpaying, but the horse you are offering for is on the advent list, which then makes people not want to trade off the list for it ^^

[patricia1]

any opinions on this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78071285&userid=951416&signature=t9WRJ6R7PZ8lKuwPOxihYg

87 rares/storepets + toxic for sorb ^^

thanks in advance (:

[lannister]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78073462&userid=796841&signature=J8lESL2edCGf76ttr5i1SQ is this a fair trade? I’m not too familiar with list pets and such so if someone could help me out that would be great thank you

[jhosie]

I keep getting rejected when trying to trade for the last missing horses in my collection

So could anyone tell me if my offers are really unfair?
In my eyes I think i am overpaying, but I am not the best at rarities

This was the last trade getting cancelled
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78072997&userid=673945&signature=EpX_iLRCxyN3mW-Wvag4Kw

So is it me who are wrong or is it just bad luck?
C$ wise it should be worth around 55 and I am offering a lot more in pet value

Rarity wise, you are overpaying, but the horse you are offering for is on the advent list, which then makes people not want to trade off the list for it ^^

Thank you very much
I just needed to know I wasn’t being unfair! I will keep trying since I don’t think I own any list pets 🙈

[Ꭺlina]

any opinions on this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78071285&userid=951416&signature=t9WRJ6R7PZ8lKuwPOxihYg

87 rares/storepets + toxic for sorb ^^

thanks in advance (:

sorbet is worth 2 green Toxics, the rares don’t make up for the gap so the sorbet side overpayd^^

[patricia1]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78073462&userid=796841&signature=J8lESL2edCGf76ttr5i1SQ is this a fair trade? I’m not too familiar with list pets and such so if someone could help me out that would be great thank you

there are no lists involved in this trade! their pet is a '08 rerelease and your pets are both store pets, their side is overpaying ^^

[lannister]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78073462&userid=796841&signature=J8lESL2edCGf76ttr5i1SQ is this a fair trade? I’m not too familiar with list pets and such so if someone could help me out that would be great thank you

there are no lists involved in this trade! their pet is a '08 rerelease and your pets are both store pets, their side is overpaying ^^

Thank you for your help ^^

[kkspecial4]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78073462&userid=796841&signature=J8lESL2edCGf76ttr5i1SQ is this a fair trade? I’m not too familiar with list pets and such so if someone could help me out that would be great thank you

there are no lists involved in this trade! their pet is a '08 rerelease and your pets are both store pets, their side is overpaying ^^

I agree that there are no list pets involved but the top side is not overpaying
This trade is fair

2008 Dog - extended into 2009 = 1 2009 Rare

The 2 Store Pets add up to 1 2009 Rare

It is up to you on if you prefer the store pets or the dog

[Taro_Queen]

I have no idea if this is fair XD

[The Plague.]

A lil’ help with this would be greatly appreciated <3!
Edit: this too:
2nd trade I counted it down to 2 09’ rares + 1 2011 rare + 1 2014 rare + 1 2015 rare. I’m not sure what tier 2 advent lists go for in 09’ rares.