The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[3000feet]

What do you all think about this? Any help is greatly appreciated <3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78038153&userid=116838&signature=w9Hgs9qwPX-SSF1FF_KX4Q

[Constellation.]

What do you all think about this? Any help is greatly appreciated <3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78038153&userid=116838&signature=w9Hgs9qwPX-SSF1FF_KX4Q

By rarity it's unfair to the blue balloon by a little less than 5 mid advents. I'd personally take it; the shima longtail doesn't normally go much higher than 1-2 mid advents so it wouldn't fully close the gap between the apple and balloon dog, and the balloon dog is much easier to trade off fairly than the apple is. (:

[heizou]

i'm not that great with items so i'd really appreciate some help with this

Just opinion since I dont know about items, I would accept! I dont have/ use many items so In my opinion, this is a miracle

thank you! could i have an opinion based on rarity?

[The Plague.]

A lil’ help with this would be greatly appreciated <3!

[Banana.]

i'm not that great with items so i'd really appreciate some help with this

Someone please correct me if I’m wrong
I counted 7 (not including the scarf) of the items that are on the item rare list that are worth ‘09 rares, that’s the kiss pps alone
The scarf is supposed to be worth an ‘09 rare (the list is a little outdated) but it often goes for an advent list. Which is where the hollyfox cat comes in.

I have no idea how to add up the rest, which, for the most part, are just worth a common/uncommon of the same year depending where you value them. Even then, your side does not add up to theirs. They’re pretty over (:

[Xeroxoe]

Hows this? xxx

[the]

Hows this? xxx

Unfair to you. Your side is worth 3 rares '09 and theirs less than 1.

[The Plague.]

Hows this? xxx

Unfair to you. Your side is = to a 2008 rare + 2009 rare, while theirs does not equal to a 2009.
(I’m going by 2 rares from 1 year = a rare from the previous year ^^)

[jhosie]

I keep getting rejected when trying to trade for the last missing horses in my collection

So could anyone tell me if my offers are really unfair?
In my eyes I think i am overpaying, but I am not the best at rarities

This was the last trade getting cancelled
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78072997&userid=673945&signature=EpX_iLRCxyN3mW-Wvag4Kw

So is it me who are wrong or is it just bad luck?
C$ wise it should be worth around 55 and I am offering a lot more in pet value

[The Plague.]

A lil’ help with this would be greatly appreciated <3!