The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Eagle's Eye]

This trade

Thanks in advance

Unfair to you due to the huge age gap.Their side is worth less than a '14 rare

[coastie_cowgirl]

Hi guys, thanks in advance for help...

I know the pet on their side recently got higher demand (I think) so I'm wondering if this is fair, or how it should be edited? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78048015&userid=40385&signature=5A4d8RkX-dEFVlKlxm51-Q

[Ꭺlina]

may I get some opinions on this trade please?
I haven’t received any better offers for the tiger in a while

[justina valentine]

may I get some opinions on this trade please?
I haven’t received any better offers for the tiger in a while

Okay so what I have gathered from this trade is:
Cucumbers can go for 2 sorbets to a non from what I have seen. So lets just say 2 nons
Joker 1 non
Bengal 1 non
Non
Spotted tribel = 2 sorbets
Sorbet
Spotted tribel + sorbet = non
That is already 6 nons
Ur dog + Wolf pps + toxic + gear back tribal = I'd say equals to maybe 2-2.5 sorbets maybe less my adding up might be a bit scratchy with these 4
All and all I think this trade is great it has amazing quantity some pets don't have the best demand but I would defiantly take it I haven't seen a big trade like this for the tiger in a while its worth maybe 7ish nons probably less but I still believe that is an amazing offer.
Hopefully that helped a bit!

[MistakenKitten]

Hello

Is this trade fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78069261&userid=938369&signature=wEeKOdq2DpFtMQVKs8KVdg

spencer : thanks!

[the]

Hi guys, thanks in advance for help...

I know the pet on their side recently got higher demand (I think) so I'm wondering if this is fair, or how it should be edited? Thanks!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78048015&userid=40385&signature=5A4d8RkX-dEFVlKlxm51-Q

Slighty unfair to you. Their pet is placed at tier 1 advent list and yours at 2 :)

[spencer]

Hello

Is this trade fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78069261&userid=938369&signature=wEeKOdq2DpFtMQVKs8KVdg

Thanks!

Unfair to them

[Abyss]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78063056&userid=377988&signature=wh7fxo_cuhZZojlVbNeWRA
Just wondering what the other side adds up to?
Thanks for your time~

[tofu.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78054344&userid=920293&signature=yV-THwoiWvJ9_xZueHcHtw

Ahh.. the quantity is INSANE but I’m not sure about how fair this is. I would really like some help.

EDIT: I also received this one, with many more high lists. Is it fair demand wise? (Would you personally take it?)
Thank you!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78058686&userid=920293&signature=6Zj0_6tarZlST6SQi9JlXg

[Ꭺlina]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78022306&userid=925404&signature=qwYHZdwi45ov5aNQvQG3dg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=78048316&userid=925404&signature=4-HHrm69fcjaGw6PAAbTfw

Would you personally accept either of these and if so which one??
Anyone? I have this as well now
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78068435&userid=925404&signature=fFLDyf4fg9O5p6Z9fAtI0A

It depends where you value your pets,
UR Aussie usually goes for 1 non but I was able to trade mine for a non + sorbet
The BA fluctuates from a sorbet up to a non

The first trade: rarity wise definitely unfair to them, but I would personally stick with the Ba and Aussie ^^
It really just depends on where you place your pets (especially BA) at and which pets you prefer

Second trade: same as above, rarity wise very unfair to them but depends on where you value the Ba and if you rather would keep quantity or the malk

Third trade: also rarity wise unfair to them, I believe the peach goes for a non? Maybe a little less?
I would personally keep the quantity ^^