The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Infectedcontent]

Would this be fair?
Image

palomino tess horse = 34-45 09 rares
Their side = 1 (the store pet) plus the more recent rares and under
Very unfair to you

Thank you uwu
Do you know the worth of the mutant malk dog?
I have no idea what to trade for it ;w;

[kkspecial4]

1] trades/viewtrade.php?id=77632698&userid=947655&signature=uOSELmUOY8o54Mlnp8QKNw
2] trades/viewtrade.php?id=77638119&userid=947655&signature=-FQwpJwu1Umcx-ubw_njUA

I'm having an auction, are either of these fair?

Trade 01 -

Unfair to the bottom - rarity wise
The top adds up to roughly 1 2010 Rare
The bottom side is worth 4 Mid 2010 Rares or 2 2009 Rares

Trade 02 -

Unfair to the bottom - rarity wise
25 C$ is fair for one of the 2017 Store Pets (as they are worth 25-30 C$)
The rest of the pets do not cover the gap for the other 3 Store Pets

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77636273&userid=834666&signature=GNtujBFNVopi_iYuwK3CPw

I am doing a paper clip and I am not sure if they are offering something better. Can someone help me?

Slightly unfair to the top - rarity wise
The two rats are fair swaps for each other as both are Early 2010 Rares
The 2011 Uncommon is extra/overpay

Thank you uwu
Do you know the worth of the mutant malk dog?
I have no idea what to trade for it ;w;

Malk Mutant = 1 Late 2009 Rare
Demand is up to you and your trading partner
This question technically belongs on the Pet Worth Thread

[protect]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77638253&userid=837282&signature=2_MqN8kcL5pFH1K4s2jR1w
is this fair?

[LaCreatura]

...is this trade fair or not...

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77617042&userid=931085&signature=zpOnPKXU4KZBxpwlXnbPZw

[Shadow.Labsky]

Syly.. no.
Chickens have near to no demand. If they were other pets like dogs sure.

[Ancient Wind]

is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77635722&userid=834615&signature=4JAc8kN2lmfj3MZ5xXQIwg

[kkspecial4]

...is this trade fair or not...

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77617042&userid=931085&signature=zpOnPKXU4KZBxpwlXnbPZw

Syly.. no.
Chickens have near to no demand. If they were other pets like dogs sure.

Demand isn’t to depend wether a trade is fair or not. You are saying that if those were dogs it would be fair? The dates do not add up. So, false.

I agree with Kaelcith
This trade is unfair to the bottom
The pets on the top side do not add up to the worth of the bottom - rarity wise
Demand is up for you and your trading partner to discuss


Demand is user based, no one can tell another user a set demand value as it changes from player to player - stating that Chickens have less demand than Dogs is false - there are players who value them the same and just look at the rarity of the pet - it may be your personal opinion that they are valued less, but that is how you see them that may not be how they are viewed by those participating in the trade

is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77635722&userid=834615&signature=4JAc8kN2lmfj3MZ5xXQIwg

Answered already on pg. 662

[Horror]

is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77635722&userid=834615&signature=4JAc8kN2lmfj3MZ5xXQIwg

If you personally use the 2:1 uncommon:rare ratio, this is fair to both sides as your cat was extended into early 2010 as well
If you use another ratio then it would be unfair to you

[LUMENS8ITE]

Is this fair?

Feeling weird sharing this once again, but I could really use an answer cause I want to get this trade out of the way.

[kkspecial4]

Is this fair?

Feeling weird sharing this once again, but I could really use an answer cause I want to get this trade out of the way.

Unfair to the bottom
The items are from the 2013 Slumber Party event and are worth 1 2013 Common/Uncommon each
The top only adds up to 3 2017 Commons or 3 2018 Uncommons