The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mookna]

I'm not sure if this is fair to both of us or if it's unfair to one or the other

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77624351&userid=925115&signature=wzqw4DVZWgKusLsDhEfpyw

[sinpai]

I ffINALLY FOUND THIS THREAD

can someone help us out? idk if I should add ovo
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77622880&userid=892996&signature=Z4zl1_wi7rrphq0L7yoITg

you need to add, it's unfair to them currently
The store pets are worth an '10 rare each making their side worth a 09 rare

I’m trading for this pet but I’m not sure which of all these pets would be fair demand wise. I appreciate the help! c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77623003&userid=358711&signature=KHPSkkw2TmyJaQV1ljv6ZQ

unfair to you rarity wise
Their side = 2 09 Rares
Your side = a bit over 6 09 R (not including demand)
Demand is decided by you but my own personal opinion about this is I wouldn't do it. Your side can got for quite a bit, but this is a decision that needs to be made by you

I'm not sure if this is fair to both of us or if it's unfair to one or the other

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77624351&userid=925115&signature=wzqw4DVZWgKusLsDhEfpyw

unfair to them rarity wise
Their side = 1 '14 Rare
Your side = 1 '16 R + 1 '17 R + 1 '18 R
Demand is up to you though and if you prefer your side or theirs

[LaCreatura]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77617042&userid=931085&signature=zpOnPKXU4KZBxpwlXnbPZw

[zitharu]

I'd love some help!
1: I'm pretty sure this is fair, as store pets are usually worth a 2010 rare (right?), but what makes me unsure is that the tiger is rare instead of very rare like store pets usually are.
2: What do I need to add/remove from my side to make it fair if I'm taking off this pet? I have very little knowledge of list pets and their worth ;w;;;
3: I personally think my side is over by a lot, but the rarity and super high demand of the raven dog makes me think otherwise ;v;

Thank you very much in advance!

[boston]

hi all.
i’m trading a list bun for rares and was wondering which is the fairer trade? i’m in a bit of a pickle. thanks in advance. <3
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621728&userid=641753&signature=ViBpooS2xxC_KKi4BAtNPA

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621861&userid=641753&signature=2h3yII-dCdT_xFT027WzIA

[GhostPants]

Which bid is the best out of all of these, and are any of them fair considering demand and rarity?
I have been asking for a few days now and im really wanting to set ranks for these bids.
The auction is for 5 sitting cats, located here XXX
Gasoline

Bid 1: XXX

Bid 2: XXX

Bid 3: XXX

Bid 4: XXX

Bid 5: XXX

EDIT: This one too! XXX

[sinpai]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77609840&userid=675160&signature=JiQ182Qx0H-IKg0Vy_QPUw Would you personally.. ;/ I know the cinnabun is above the non tier now, but I don’t know how good it is.

this is completely up to your preference and values, do what will make you the happiest. Trading down any high list can be difficult but the cinnabun was just placed there recently for a reason and demand differs from person to person. I don't like to trade up anymore so I wouldn't do it personally but that's because I like advents/september pets more than I like the high pets but that's just my preference

hi all.
i’m trading a list bun for rares and was wondering which is the fairer trade? i’m in a bit of a pickle. thanks in advance. <3
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621728&userid=641753&signature=ViBpooS2xxC_KKi4BAtNPA

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621861&userid=641753&signature=2h3yII-dCdT_xFT027WzIA

the bun = 6-7 09 R + 1 09 UC
Bid one; 7 09 R + 1 09 UC + 1 '10 R + 1 '11 UC
They are overpaying a little bit
Bid two; worth 5 09 R
Unfair to you

[Redpanda]

Hi! this is a Bid I received for my moonswirl. I know it’s currently unfair but what if a UR Aussie and BA are added? Would the quantity value be enough?

[hoss-sauce11]

omggggg Idk if this is fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77624811&userid=920989&signature=qyWAXwvjilaCfapVY5TOKg

[Mavy]

Trade

Was this fair? c: