The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GhostPants]

Which bid is the best out of all of these, and are any of them fair considering demand and rarity?
I have been asking for a few days now and im really wanting to set ranks for these bids.
The auction is for 5 sitting cats, located here XXX
Gasoline

Bid 1: XXX

Bid 2: XXX

Bid 3: XXX

Bid 4: XXX

Bid 5: XXX

[Mistwing]

Is this trade fair?

[dakotapaws]

hey guys!
checking this trade again!
how fair is it?
what needs added/removed?

edit: and this one too?

edit 2: aaaaand this bid

[boston]

hi all.
i’m trading a list bun for rares and was wondering which is the fairer trade? i’m in a bit of a pickle. thanks in advance. <3
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621728&userid=641753&signature=ViBpooS2xxC_KKi4BAtNPA

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621861&userid=641753&signature=2h3yII-dCdT_xFT027WzIA

[GhostPants]

Which bid is the best out of all of these, and are any of them fair considering demand and rarity?
I have been asking for a few days now and im really wanting to set ranks for these bids.
The auction is for 5 sitting cats, located here XXX
Gasoline

Bid 1: XXX

Bid 2: XXX

Bid 3: XXX

Bid 4: XXX

Bid 5: XXX

EDIT: This one too! XXX

[little_fuzzy_tiger]

is this fair? i really like the blue rose dog but i think its still under for my horse
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621488&userid=192025&signature=ZsCwGhSXhDHgeVO4GCnddg

[Underworld]

Which one is more fair?

1. For just one dog

2. For the Set of dogs

3. For the Set of Dogs

[xayah.]

I ffINALLY FOUND THIS THREAD

can someone help us out? idk if I should add ovo
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77622880&userid=892996&signature=Z4zl1_wi7rrphq0L7yoITg

[c o w]

I’m trading for this pet but I’m not sure which of all these pets would be fair demand wise. I appreciate the help! c:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77623003&userid=358711&signature=KHPSkkw2TmyJaQV1ljv6ZQ

[Mookna]

I'm not sure if this is fair to both of us or if it's unfair to one or the other

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77624351&userid=925115&signature=wzqw4DVZWgKusLsDhEfpyw