The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[GhostPants]

Which bid is the best out of all of these, and are any of them fair considering demand and rarity?
I have been asking for a few days now and im really wanting to set ranks for these bids.
The auction is for 5 sitting cats, located here XXX
Gasoline

Bid 1: XXX

Bid 2: XXX

Bid 3: XXX

Bid 4: XXX

Bid 5: XXX

[Ploegy]

boop. could someone lend me a hand with this one?

[popping star]

boop. could someone lend me a hand with this one?

It's fair.
Both sides are worth an early 2010 rare. c:

[sumatra.]

boop. could someone lend me a hand with this one?

2016 Store Pet = Early 2010 Rare,
So this is fair

is this remotely fair? tysm

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77585165&userid=812148&signature=eRpfWVV8geJ5YX0QPfONzA

?? I dunno if anyone awnsered

I would think so.. But aren't some of those store items? and the token itself can go for 3-4 chicken dollars alone no?

Heavens Wings; 2009 August ——— 2009 Rare
Red Cloak; 2011 January ————— 2011 Uncommon
Thief’s Dagger; 2013 January —— 2013 Uncommon
Black Button-Up Shirt; April 2013- 2013 Uncommon
Plasma Scythe; June 2013 ———— 2013 Uncommon
Bat Cookie; 2018 October ———— 2018 Common

I typically value items at an uncommon from their release date, as do many other users so that’s what I’m going to do here, with the exception of the heavens wings and bat cookie.
Due to the fact they are from 2009, I value the wings at an ‘09 rare. I have had a hard time trying to trade for them for only an ‘09 uncommon.

Therefore just the wings alone would be overpay on your side. If you happen to value them at a 2009 uncommon, then you are still overpaying with all the rest of the added items.

[Mistwing]

Is this trade fair?

[GhostPants]

Which bid is the best out of all of these, and are any of them fair considering demand and rarity?
I have been asking for a few days now and im really wanting to set ranks for these bids.
The auction is for 5 sitting cats, located here XXX
Gasoline

Bid 1: XXX

Bid 2: XXX

Bid 3: XXX

Bid 4: XXX

Bid 5: XXX

[dakotapaws]

hey guys!
checking this trade again!
how fair is it?
what needs added/removed?

[kkspecial4]

how's this? thanks for help! <3

Unfair to the top - rarity wise
Top adds up to 4 2009 Rares
Bottom adds up to slightly over 3 2009 Rares

Demand is up to you and your trading partner

[Shadow.Labsky]

Okay, but honestly I feel like they are trying to scam me here.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621110&userid=891221&signature=yTmv084dJJ0pkZcsMeH8Fg

"Well I believe that the GWJ is around a non. And the 3 advents all add up to around below a non and I could add something if you would like. I could add the blue rose or keep the trade like this. Or make a 1 for 1 zebra for ur dog "

How could three advents add up to a non? I don't believe the GWJ has that much demand (anymore... might have used to)... but it isn't placed anywhere near a non.
Please help me... originally they said THIS was fair... ??? No??

"This adds up to two nons"
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77609067&userid=891221&signature=gbcjXVapcGjetFIQSqhUkA
WAY less than they offered me *this time* and *this time* they said it "almost" adds up... what the heck?
Seriously help me figure this out. I MIGHT be missing something but I don't think so and I might report this to an admin if it comes down to it being obvious that they're lying about worths/values.

[popping star]

Okay, but honestly I feel like they are trying to scam me here.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77621110&userid=891221&signature=yTmv084dJJ0pkZcsMeH8Fg

"Well I believe that the GWJ is around a non. And the 3 advents all add up to around below a non and I could add something if you would like. I could add the blue rose or keep the trade like this. Or make a 1 for 1 zebra for ur dog :)"

How could three advents add up to a non? I don't believe the GWJ has that much demand (anymore... might have used to)... but it isn't placed anywhere near a non.
Please help me... originally they said THIS was fair... ??? No??

"This adds up to two nons"
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77609067&userid=891221&signature=gbcjXVapcGjetFIQSqhUkA
WAY less than they offered me *this time* and *this time* they said it "almost" adds up... what the heck?
Seriously help me figure this out. I MIGHT be missing something but I don't think so and I might report this to an admin if it comes down to it being obvious that they're lying about worths/values.

Neither trade adds up to a single non let alone two.
The sunback is worth 2 nons, so both trades are unfair to you list-wise.

This trade is worth 2 sorbets + a speckled rat.
A non is worth 3 sorbets.

This trade is basically only worth a GWJ. The advent bun and rares add nothing to this trade due to how little they are worth compared to the GWJ and Sunback.