The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Kouriander]

Is this fair ??

Wrong link! Find the link at the bottom of the trade, that's the one you want! <3

Oops my bad ! Thank you for letting me know ! <3

Would this be fair?

[kkspecial4]

Oops my bad ! Thank you for letting me know ! <3

Would this be fair?

Unfair to the top - rarity wise
Demand is up to you and your trading partner

Top side adds up to slightly over 1 2016 Uncommon + 1 2017 Uncommon
Bottom side adds up to 1 2016 Uncommon + 1 2018 Uncommon

[Oppacifyy]

??

[grimalkin_grins]

I know the other pets and items don't add to the worth of this trade, but is it fair? (x)

[Horror]

I know the other pets and items don't add to the worth of this trade, but is it fair? (x)

2 2017 stores = 2 (mid) 2010 rares = a (mid) 09 rare
The nick sunback pps is worth 2 09 rares so it's unfair to them

[dakotapaws]

hey guys!
checking this trade again!
how fair is it?
what needs added/removed?

[Ecko]

??

The store pet is worth two 2009 rares so it is a fair swap for the warrior. The other horse is overpay.

I know the other pets and items don't add to the worth of this trade, but is it fair? (x)

The very rare dog on their side is worth two 2009 rares while your store pets are worth a 2010 rare each or a 2009 rare together so it is unfair to them.

[Wild things]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77617999&userid=791541&signature=iGlawU-yx1AttdP0bUIrMg

How to make this fair?

[cup of cocoa]

Is this trade fair?

[GhostPants]

Which bid is the best out of all of these, and are any of them fair considering demand and rarity?
I have been asking for a few days now and im really wanting to set ranks for these bids.
The auction is for 5 sitting cats, located here XXX
Gasoline

Bid 1: XXX

Bid 2: XXX

Bid 3: XXX

Bid 4: XXX

Bid 5: XXX