The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[helena moonshadow]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574916&userid=729746&signature=vbP3hSbeuWZD8M9TSpL5LA
Is this fair? Thank you!

[KickingPixies]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77540462&userid=769655&signature=vRphH4IiGCdch9cwdKeYfQ

would this be fair? it's a bit of a mix-match, so i'm unsure.

[MidnightDuchess]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77575720&userid=845505&signature=nVsYnUXGi3pFYYKCc0P5HQ[/quote]

Fair?

[Targaryen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576323&userid=702384&signature=MTlo-4Vk6bcuGkZvWybuLA


thoughts?

They are overpaying. A lot of the pets they are asking for except about 4 have very low to little demand/unwanted/things that would be thrown around as gifts.
75 C$ sounds good, I'd accept 50. A lot of people (once its after 2014ish,) charge .50 to 1 C$ per pet - 3 C$ per pet (which don't really get bought, because again... it's common to get gifted pets like that.

I've seen many times, 2012 commons go for 2 C$ - 4 C$, and after 2014 things become like... free.. "buy one get one free" or "here's a gift"

So yeah, they're overpaying unless they REALLY want the pets.

You could buy a low advent with 75 C$ I believe. Are your pets worth that? no

Agreed for the most part. The guides for C$ value for common pets are decent and all but I don't feel it accurately reflects the trading environment for lower value pets and most C$ stores offer "pay what you want"/"10 for 1c$"/"5 for 1c$" for pets on the more recent half of CS' lifespan.
It is incredibly hard to get more out of common pets and I'm fairly certain even if you valued the common pets at an average of the 4-5 different C$ rates given in the C$ worth guide it'd be the same value if not under. It's a bit ridiculous to me to imply the other user is being unfair when its... quite a generous offer in contrast to the actual going rates of pets.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574916&userid=729746&signature=vbP3hSbeuWZD8M9TSpL5LA
Is this fair? Thank you!

Unless I missed list pets hidden in there, it's highly unfair to you and the 09 rares don't really make much of a dent in the Shima Wolf's value.

[dinolover519]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574951&userid=939615&signature=loLMJRzYkNiG6LsLEb-qzw

Help please! Still not good with rares

[kököchin]

I have been here for a while and I know the list pretty well but accounting demand and all the ur bengal is still going for a sorbet right ?

ur bengal = sorbet ? [demand wise]

[Asvoria]

Heyaa so I'd love your thoughts on these offers for my auction:

I have three malk dragons and the store griffin set UFA and there are some offers on all of the auction pets or on a few of them.
I'd just love to hear your opinions on each trade and maybe which one/s you'd personally accept.

1. Red & Green Dragon: 12x 09 rares

2. Green Dragon: 7x 09 rares

3. Grey Dragon: Blue Ice Rat + 16x 09 rares/ store pets + 100C$

4. All Griffins & All Dragons: Wolf PPS

5. PPS Griffin & Green Dragon: '08 vr rat & warrior

6. All Griffins & All Dragons: Green Fronted Holly + 300C$

Thanks for any help!

[Shadow.Labsky]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576089&userid=891221&signature=psyaEn64ymINaHMriQ8zlQ

please help!
is this fair for my Zonkey?

aaa

[null]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574951&userid=939615&signature=loLMJRzYkNiG6LsLEb-qzw

Help please! Still not good with rares

if you use the 2:1 ratio,

bottom
2013 = 2 2014
2 2014 = 4 2015
4 2015 = 8 2016
8 2016 = 16 2017

top
2014 = 2 2015
2 2015 + 2015 = 2016
7 2016 + 2016= 14 2017
=14 2017 + 2017 = 15 2017

it is unfair to the bottom by 1 2017 rare, but demand is up to you and your trading partner, and it also depends how you value quantity

[Targaryen]

I have been here for a while and I know the list pretty well but accounting demand and all the ur bengal is still going for a sorbet right ?

ur bengal = sorbet ? [demand wise]

Sorbets Bengals appear to be going for a sorbet atm but keep in mind every OMGSR will eventually moved above the gap when they are finally discussed.

i have weekend brain excuse me sorry LOL