The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Shadow.Labsky]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576089&userid=891221&signature=psyaEn64ymINaHMriQ8zlQ

please help!
is this fair for my Zonkey?

Dare I say it isnt?
The only way I can view it as fair is if a lot of those are on your wishlist

A few. I am wanting to trade-down.
I'm just focused on demand. Does the alien horse pony pps alien thing on the mainlist (I think) have good demand? Does the sept list dog have good demand... and is the rest.. does it add up?
If you just count all the '09s as a mid-sept, then let's say there's 2 mid septs, the horse pps alien thing, items, and the other lists... is it fair?

[choerry]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77553112&userid=845505&signature=noqeSp90ymeeTxN8RB4rAQ

Fair?

Another:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77575720&userid=845505&signature=nVsYnUXGi3pFYYKCc0P5HQ

for no.1 , the line tribal is worth about 580c$

on your side, there is 480 C$ and a few storepets

its up to you how you value store pets, but..
the current store pets are worth 20c$ each, or 60c$ for 4 = 60-80c$
the last set of store pets are worth 20c$ each (25 for the pps, thats what most people value it at) or 70c$ for 5 = 90-125c$

already, that equals at least 630 c$

i have to go, so i cant really work out the rest, but i think its overpay on your side

get a second opinion though

and im the second person in

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77575720&userid=845505&signature=nVsYnUXGi3pFYYKCc0P5HQ

this trade, help appreciated?

[Supreme]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576323&userid=702384&signature=MTlo-4Vk6bcuGkZvWybuLA


thoughts?

[Likaon]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576323&userid=702384&signature=MTlo-4Vk6bcuGkZvWybuLA


thoughts?

Personally, I wouldn't take it, because the older pets are worth more

[SarcasticLoner]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77566438&userid=381069&signature=szPcbN4hmLj-vlPZqftFSg

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77574612&userid=381069&signature=gyVkVVdkE4xn-JSYCRAv7A

Can I get opinions on these please? c:

[Shadow.Labsky]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576089&userid=891221&signature=psyaEn64ymINaHMriQ8zlQ

please help!
is this fair for my Zonkey?

[Targaryen]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576323&userid=702384&signature=MTlo-4Vk6bcuGkZvWybuLA


thoughts?

Personally, I wouldn't take it, because the older pets are worth more

How do you justify that? I've never seen common pets go for so much C$ and there aren't any rares as far as I've saw
It looks like they're overpaying a lot (to me) but I value common pets very lowly in terms of C$.

[choerry]

this ?

[the]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77553112&userid=845505&signature=noqeSp90ymeeTxN8RB4rAQ

Fair?

Another:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77575720&userid=845505&signature=nVsYnUXGi3pFYYKCc0P5HQ

for no.1 , the line tribal is worth about 580c$

on your side, there is 480 C$ and a few storepets

its up to you how you value store pets, but..
the current store pets are worth 20c$ each, or 60c$ for 4 = 60-80c$
the last set of store pets are worth 20c$ each (25 for the pps, thats what most people value it at) or 70c$ for 5 = 90-125c$

already, that equals at least 630 c$

i have to go, so i cant really work out the rest, but i think its overpay on your side

get a second opinion though

and im the second person in

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77575720&userid=845505&signature=nVsYnUXGi3pFYYKCc0P5HQ

this trade, help appreciated?

It actually doesn't work like that.
480 C$ = speckled rat tier (18 mid advents). The line tribal is worth 29.5 mid advents, so the gap is roughly a skeleton pps which your side doesn't add up to, so they're overpaying. It's up to you if you want to take it or not though.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576323&userid=702384&signature=MTlo-4Vk6bcuGkZvWybuLA


thoughts?

Uncommons and below don't have a set value, so that depends on how you personally value the pets. Here is a few price suggestions that may help you.

[Shadow.Labsky]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77576323&userid=702384&signature=MTlo-4Vk6bcuGkZvWybuLA


thoughts?

Personally, I wouldn't take it, because the older pets are worth more

How do you justify that? I've never seen common pets go for so much C$ and there aren't any rares as far as I've saw
It looks like they're overpaying a lot (to me) but I value common pets very lowly in terms of C$.

They are overpaying. A lot of the pets they are asking for except about 4 have very low to little demand/unwanted/things that would be thrown around as gifts.
75 C$ sounds good, I'd accept 50. A lot of people (once its after 2014ish,) charge .50 to 1 C$ per pet - 3 C$ per pet (which don't really get bought, because again... it's common to get gifted pets like that.

I've seen many times, 2012 commons go for 2 C$ - 4 C$, and after 2014 things become like... free.. "buy one get one free" or "here's a gift"

So yeah, they're overpaying unless they REALLY want the pets.

You could buy a low advent with 75 C$ I believe. Are your pets worth that? no