The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[clarke,]

*Personally* would you take this?

i don't know if it's fair, but you asked for personal opinion. i would definitely accept.

i wouldn't accept, but that's because i value the eat me/drink me higher than the other pets (who have okay demand at best).

[Mhynt]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77180709&userid=542542&signature=5nY1Tpeu_J0rkPeOy0_kOw

So, I'm thinking this is way overpay on their part. But at the same time, that specific candy cane horse is worth 60C$ in value, while I payed 20C$ for each pet.

Idk, what do you guys think?

[knight.]

hii ! is this fair ?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77093199&userid=948478&signature=KTDUJSOXckcZYz9VJmn8pQ
thanks for your help !!

[FelisUrbanus]

Hello ^^

I accepted on sight but it occurred to me afterwards that this trade might be unfair to the offering side. Is this trade fair?

Year gaps more than 2 years make me panic... I'll send them a gift if they overoffered.

it was actually unfair to you.
using the 2:1 ratio, their side was worth slightly less than one 11' common [if i've done my math right lol]. ^-^

Thank you ^^

I'm glad someone got interested in that dog at last, at any rate

[Galactia]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77180709&userid=542542&signature=5nY1Tpeu_J0rkPeOy0_kOw

So, I'm thinking this is way overpay on their part. But at the same time, that specific candy cane horse is worth 60C$ in value, while I payed 20C$ for each pet.

Idk, what do you guys think?

their pet is a tier 2 advent list, worth roughly 4-5 09' rares.
your side adds up to about 7-8 09' rares, so it's unfair to you. c:

[Mhynt]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77180709&userid=542542&signature=5nY1Tpeu_J0rkPeOy0_kOw

So, I'm thinking this is way overpay on their part. But at the same time, that specific candy cane horse is worth 60C$ in value, while I payed 20C$ for each pet.

Idk, what do you guys think?

their pet is a tier 2 advent list, worth roughly 4-5 09' rares.
your side adds up to about 7-8 09' rares, so it's unfair to you. c:

Oh! Well, thank you ^_^ I had no idea it was worth that

[.Squid]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77182829&userid=638527&signature=AUCsVrQFIzBzdPJ8gYxVqA

[baestille]

Is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77182829&userid=638527&signature=AUCsVrQFIzBzdPJ8gYxVqA

unfair to them i think
pretty sure a 2017 store pet = 1 09 rare

[daydreamer99]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77177351&userid=179062&signature=cnC9OmQMnYU_LiQLMeHCtg

Curious mostly because of the difference in dates and the demand of the banner pup (that seems to be one of the more common ones now, and I already have a few)

^^^

[Lopez]

sfnjfnekj
What needs to be added to make this fair?
Thanks in advance!

would we be able to get a 2nd opinion? My trade partner is worried that they're overtrading, and I want to make sure it's fair for them as well as us!