The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[The Plague.]

how fair is this?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77159736&userid=736731&signature=6F--wUjcQEC8UoKQyCvGyg

[QueenSiren]

Is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77169876&userid=897504&signature=ilZQixIMng8_DhdMGxbaOQ

[rhaenyra.]

Hello! I'm stumped on this trade:

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77169625&userid=771435&signature=hsrU_N_54_92yoqf0mnx-g

Any help is great appreciated

[archaic persona]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77167057&userid=947194&signature=QhEiys7vey3D8OP9Ef6azg
Is this fair?

[bostonlobstah]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77170261

Is this fair??? They told me the eyeball is high demand...
But I would take the eyeball out of circulation anyways so not going to get anything from it....
Is the eyeball guy really that valuable?

[SyrupBean]

Hello, would this trade be fair? Thank you. c:

[kkspecial4]

Is this a fair trade?

Unfair to the top side of the trade by the C$ alone - the pets are extra.

Mid 2010 Rare = 25-30 C$
Late 2010 Rare = 20-25 C$
2010 Uncommon = 6-9 C$ each
2018 Uncommon = Less than 1 C$

Total Bottom Side Worth: 66-85 C$

*The Unknown Rarity pets could potentially be at the most 2018 Rares or at the least 2018 Uncommons - worth 1-3 C$ or less than 1 C$ depending on how they turn out - they do not have a heavy effect on the trade.

- For the sake of the evaluation I valued all of the 2018 pets at 0.5 C$ each - basically all at the worth of an Uncommon -

*Note; Uncommons and below do not have a set C$ value - it is up to you and your trading partner on where you value them - the prices provided in the evaluation given above were taken from a rough guideline provided by the C$ Worth Thread

I've just been sent this trade: https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77169210&userid=769655&signature=My-9rmUEMVMjFgE0iTZbQw
Is this fair? My first impression is it's not but I wanted to double check.

Unfair to the bottom side of the trade.

2016 Store Pet = 1 Early 2010 Rare

The top side only adds up to slightly over 1 2015 Rare.

how fair is this?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77159736&userid=736731&signature=6F--wUjcQEC8UoKQyCvGyg

UR Apple = 15 Mid Advents

Dark Leopard = 8.5 Mid Advents
July Lioness = 2 2012 Rares - with demand it seems to fetch 1 Low/Mid Advent

Rarity wise this is unfair to the UR Apple - demand is up to you and your trading partner.

Is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77169876&userid=897504&signature=ilZQixIMng8_DhdMGxbaOQ

Very unfair to the bottom side of the trade.

Dark Purple 2nd Gen Dog = 2008 Rare - extended into August 2009 = 1 Mid 2009 Rare
Dark Green Rave Dog = 1 Mid 2010 Rare

The top side only adds up to a little over 1 2016 Rare.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77170261

Is this fair??? They told me the eyeball is high demand...
But I would take the eyeball out of circulation anyways so not going to get anything from it....
Is the eyeball guy really that valuable?

Wrong link - use the share trade link at the bottom of the trade.

And no - at the moment the Eyeball Banner Dog has an inflated demand but at most will be a 2018 Uncommon/Rare after the event and the hype dies down, so will the demand with the Banner Dog (if you are referring to the Eyeball Banner Dog).

[Rbpuppy]

Does anyone know the demand on a Moonswirl? I’m currently working out a trade for one and I just want to know if they’re still popular (:

[Infectedcontent]

Trade
Unfair?

[Kitty&Cats]

Hello, would this trade be fair? Thank you. c:

I would personally take it because store pets have a lot more demand than those common-uncommon pets. Not very many people like to trade down. Hope I helped and feel free to get other advice!