The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[hinata]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77160813&userid=806439&signature=EetTezk1X_wjPG_kUu6ERA
Would this be fair?

Unfair to the unicorn rare side. Most (if not all) of those items are free and are not worth much. The space event pets have a good demand as well

Okay, thanks!

[coppercanary]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77160813&userid=806439&signature=EetTezk1X_wjPG_kUu6ERA
Would this be fair?

Unfair to the unicorn rare side. Most (if not all) of those items are free and are not worth much. The space event pets have a good demand as well

Okay, thanks!

I personally would say it’s unfair to the bottom. Using the 2:1 ratio four of the uncommons would be fair, with the rest as overpay; and with the 4:1 ratio, the uncommons by themselves are fair. Whichever ratio you use, the items are overpay. I’d like to add that demand is user-based and varies from player to player. I would not give any extra for space event pets.

Is this trade fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77160488&userid=861757&signature=MjqWZ5KwVHj5gB63XxDm-Q

This is fair. Two pets of one year (same rarity) = another of the year before (again, same rarity).

[mynameisbacon]

fair?

Thanks for any and all help!

[sumatra.]

*Personally* would you take this?

[.:Cleverfox:.]

*Personally* would you take this?

No, the ba is the only very good pet in there, I think you might be able to swap a ba for a eat me/drink me but I’m not entirely sure- either way I wouldn’t

[killukawa]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77041980&userid=866559&signature=yaLh1XTIh81Ca2e16RgqZg
Did i do a fair trade?

[Kaminarii]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77158131&userid=857986&signature=58M4lEvtkV_w-cnOU-yNVA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77155336&userid=857986&signature=s0VlsrfgMXP_hQqW1WroCQ

wondering about the fairness of these two trades! <3

[sumatra.]

*Personally* would you take this?

[Furiouswolf]

Hi, is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=77097125&userid=22990&signature=MgMbrSBKLtD4VYOMtFxtGQ
i'm terrible with items. i'd like more than one answer
If it helps:
Item: Cupid Arrow
valentine 2009
Item: Arrow Quiver
valentine 2009
Item: Oversized Sweater
christmas 2014
Item: Snowy path
christmas 2015
Item: Blizzard
christmas 2015
Item: Poppy
2017 birthday
Item: Poppies
2017 birthday
animal egg 20
easter 2012
Item: Mushroom
can't find when it's from?

[Ruiying]

Thoughts on this trade? Thanks!