The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Twistytal]

Which of the below would be fairer?
Trade 1 , Trade 2
Thanks in advance.

[siilvxr]

is this fair?

It's unfair for you, the C$ isn't enough to make up for the year difference.

thank you so much for the answer! is there a way i could edit the trade to make it fair for me?

I'd like help about this as well! really liking this trade tbh

Not so great with item rarities, how is this:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76992843&userid=775407&signature=Aw5oXdsriDUtpLzieD0Fzg

I'm on the other side of this, so I'd appreciate any answer too!

I could be wrong but I believe the rare dog side is over? because items usually aren't worth a lot ... although it could be a matter of personal choice and opinion

[ηαтαlιє]

Is the spider more worth than the zebra?
I would only swap it for this reason cause the spider isn´t on my wishlist...

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77003265&userid=358634&signature=j5aH9Cnt_h8uw3orrFghzg

Think nobody answered yet. Please help me :3

[★Juuzou Suzuya★]

It's unfair for you, the C$ isn't enough to make up for the year difference.

thank you so much for the answer! is there a way i could edit the trade to make it fair for me?

I'd like help about this as well! really liking this trade tbh

3C$ is worth roughly a 2016 rare, so their side is worth a 2015 rare + a 2016 rare. They'd have to add around 9 2016 rares, or 4 2015 rares + a 2016 rare, or 2 2014 rares + a 2016 rare, or 1 2013 rare + a 2016 rare. Not sure if it's 100% correct and of course it's up to you and your trading partner to decide what works best for both of you.

And the second link you said isn't the correct one, I can't view the trade.

[siilvxr]

3C$ is worth roughly a 2016 rare, so their side is worth a 2015 rare + a 2016 rare. They'd have to add around 9 2016 rares, or 4 2015 rares + a 2016 rare, or 2 2014 rares + a 2016 rare, or 1 2013 rare + a 2016 rare. Not sure if it's 100% correct and of course it's up to you and your trading partner to decide what works best for both of you.

And the second link you said isn't the correct one, I can't view the trade.

thank you so much for the help! here's the correct link, sorry : click!

[★Juuzou Suzuya★]

3C$ is worth roughly a 2016 rare, so their side is worth a 2015 rare + a 2016 rare. They'd have to add around 9 2016 rares, or 4 2015 rares + a 2016 rare, or 2 2014 rares + a 2016 rare, or 1 2013 rare + a 2016 rare. Not sure if it's 100% correct and of course it's up to you and your trading partner to decide what works best for both of you.

And the second link you said isn't the correct one, I can't view the trade.

thank you so much for the help! here's the correct link, sorry : click!

I would definitely accept that. That banner pet will be rare at best and the hype on them will die down soon, I would take the overpay while I can get it. Still up to you though~

[fernn_]

Is this one fair? Thanks for any help!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77066905&userid=717505&signature=LbUc9pqybmDTadG0eG0aqQ

[Salika]

Hey, I'm not sure about trades with items, so I' asking here.
I guess the Items were from Halloween somwhere between 2014 and 2015, can somebody help?
to the trade

[★Juuzou Suzuya★]

Hey, I'm not sure about trades with items, so I' asking here.
I guess the Items were from Halloween somwhere between 2014 and 2015, can somebody help?
to the trade

An item is worth an uncommon from the year it was released in.
These items are from Halloween 2014 so they're overpaying

[sigonyth]

I'm rly not sure about this trade since I have no clue what the lion pps is actually worth - would someone mind helping me out? :0 thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77063102&userid=247373&signature=TTnqysPXhlZO_Tu7SDQ4RA