The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[popping star]

Hello. I had a trade today that someone cancelled. I need to show them how fair it was so they understand I wasn't lying about it being fair. It is a very fair trade. They believe it to be unfair. Please help all you wonderful people who know trade values better than I.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77018208&userid=188993&signature=ktXgnu-9slP5WB9sDBspFw

Thank you in advance.

It's actually unfair to you due to the date gaps.
Even if the two unknown rarities end up rare, you're still overpaying. ^^

[kököchin]

would you accept this ?
thank you for all advice ! I am really poor with trade ups so all the help is appreciated c:

Their side is worth almost a UR Lion so they're overpaying. It's up to you if you want to take this or not.

thank you c: another opinion?

Agreed. It's unfair to the top.
I'd personally take it as it's really good quantity. ^^

okay thank you!

[Fig]

Hi! I don't know if my 'I want this' blinders are causing me to get into a bad trade or not. Am I over or under offering?
For UR Lion

[VRA]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77004107&userid=656404&signature=-YNnnnxB9iy6KWb8zDbdaw

Fair and would you personally take this? Thank you to whoever helps! <3

[ordinary people]

Thanks a lot c:

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77004107&userid=656404&signature=-YNnnnxB9iy6KWb8zDbdaw

Fair and would you personally take this? Thank you to whoever helps! <3

I'd say they're overpaying. The 30C$ would be enough for the Store Pet by itself. c:

[Aphrodisiac]

fair?

4 of those items according to the CS Item Guide is worth a 2009 rare and your other items are just older. Not sure of worth but I do know they are overpaying (:

Thank you! Second opinions please?

[hinata]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77025601&userid=806439&signature=WYioLit0hr8b7sdiHyUf5g

Is this fair?

[GreenbeanGummy]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77027809&userid=948896&signature=ux7qbrZkVFJvgPUIzVG0wA is this fair for 73 tokens???

[killukawa]

Are any of these fair :')
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76963082&userid=866559&signature=rqvnDHo5I5mho4qXVgtAUw
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76935720&userid=866559&signature=FNPiPG6FAsHUPrXqTk0wlQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76795358&userid=866559&signature=ZEZwsIXpy3-Jc9rV3eQ2UA