The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ScuroFenice]

I just sent this back over as a suggestion to someone who was looking for items to trade, adding the WL pets they had on their side. I'm pretty sure I'm overpaying....a lot but I wanted to see what some other opinions were. Here's also what I wrote down as the item worth in the trades according to the "What is this item worth?" thread. I'm wondering what I could do to make it more fair for my side.

Blink Bat: Couldn't find it but the same bat from its year, the Vincent Bat is worth a mid 2011 Uncommon
Animal Egg 23: 2012 Uncommon
Vampire Wig: Late 2012 Common
Animal Egg 54: 2015 Uncommon
Chocolate Splatters: Doesn't show in the items thread but it's from 2015 so, 2015 Common?
Watery BG: Is from last year so 2017 Common.
Fruit Mince Pie: From 2013 Christmas event, 2013 Common

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77026064&userid=247513&signature=NCq2MQqwzCkfdlk-0BnI3w

[kököchin]

would you accept this ?
thank you for all advice ! I am really poor with trade ups so all the help is appreciated c:

[Via.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77026358&userid=838986&signature=n_lFIkwzEafthCe5FxYY7A
Is this fair for a balloon dog? PM me

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77026358&userid=838986&signature=n_lFIkwzEafthCe5FxYY7A
Is this fair for a balloon dog? PM me

It's unfair to you. Their side is worth almost a Line Tribal, which is a couple tiers above the Balloon Dog. (:

would you accept this ?
thank you for all advice ! I am really poor with trade ups so all the help is appreciated c:

Their side is worth almost a UR Lion so they're overpaying. It's up to you if you want to take this or not.

[Jained]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77026454&userid=827874&signature=1rgjzeu_KlHXIHGPKDewMw

would this be fair? im bad at calculating

[kököchin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77026358&userid=838986&signature=n_lFIkwzEafthCe5FxYY7A
Is this fair for a balloon dog? PM me

It's unfair to you. Their side is worth almost a Line Tribal, which is a couple tiers above the Balloon Dog. (:

would you accept this ?
thank you for all advice ! I am really poor with trade ups so all the help is appreciated c:

Their side is worth almost a UR Lion so they're overpaying. It's up to you if you want to take this or not.

thank you c: another opinion?

[popping star]

would you accept this ?
thank you for all advice ! I am really poor with trade ups so all the help is appreciated c:

Their side is worth almost a UR Lion so they're overpaying. It's up to you if you want to take this or not.

thank you c: another opinion?

Agreed. It's unfair to the top.
I'd personally take it as it's really good quantity. ^^

[Equid Phantasm]

Hello. I had a trade today that someone cancelled. I need to show them how fair it was so they understand I wasn't lying about it being fair. It is a very fair trade. They believe it to be unfair. Please help all you wonderful people who know trade values better than I.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77018208&userid=188993&signature=ktXgnu-9slP5WB9sDBspFw

Thank you in advance.

[nobxdy]

Hello. I had a trade today that someone cancelled. I need to show them how fair it was so they understand I wasn't lying about it being fair. It is a very fair trade. They believe it to be unfair. Please help all you wonderful people who know trade values better than I.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77018208&userid=188993&signature=ktXgnu-9slP5WB9sDBspFw

Thank you in advance.

It's unfair to you. Your pets are worth more because they're a lot older than theirs.

[Inactive User 1]

Never thought I'd use this thread lol.

Bid 1 | Bid 2

These are two offers on an auction I'm doing, and they both seem good to me.
I really like what's offered in both, so I can't really decide.

Could I please have a second opinion? Any responses are appreciated!

Also, does anyone know which warrior cat that is? Haven't read the books in forever. :')