The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[the]

is this fair?

Basilisk = 3-4 rares '09
Very rare '09 = 2 rares '09
Store pet '16 = early rare '10, so 2 rares '09 in total
Your side is worth 4, so that's considered fair.

i honestly don't know what to offer on the kitsune, is this fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76554548&userid=862889&signature=6RJ4YuhL6T6tv9JvWFYczw

Store pet '13 = early rare '09
Your side = 3 rares '09 + uncommon '09
The kitsunes seem to have a good demand, but personally I wouldn't overpay for them that much.

[kkspecial4]

does the brown border collie have any special demand i should be aware of before accepting this trade? i'd just like to double check, thank you <3

I do not believe there is any special demand on it - however demand is user based and can vary from player to player.

Yellow/Brown Cookie = Tier 7 Advent

Brown Border Collie = Tier 7 Advent

Rarity wise this is fair as both dogs are on the same tier making it a simple swap.
Up to you on which of the dogs you prefer.

[averys]

Is this fair?
x

Thanks in advance!

[kkspecial4]

Is this fair?
x

Thanks in advance!

Unfair to the 2012 Store Pet.

2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares

The top side only adds up to 1.5 2009 Rares.
They would need to add another 2010 Rare to make it fair rarity wise.
The 2018 Uncommons do not help the trade at all because they are too recent.

[Zelfie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76551229&userid=921063&signature=ol1xq5ONM_dop0gdpPb8Mw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76551890&userid=921063&signature=agKaqBdIrpajhEaGlH_CPw

Any thoughts on these? Thanks to all that help

[sumatra.]

Would love some help/opinions on these trades:
trade #1
trade #2
trade #3
trade #4

[the]

Is this fair?
x

Thanks in advance!

Slighty unfair to you. Your store pet is worth 2 rares '09 and their side is worth 1.5.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76551229&userid=921063&signature=ol1xq5ONM_dop0gdpPb8Mw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76551890&userid=921063&signature=agKaqBdIrpajhEaGlH_CPw

Any thoughts on these? Thanks to all that help

In the first trade your side is worth roughly 2 sorbets + balloon dog and the zebra is worth 3 nons (9 sorbets), so rarity wise they're overpaying a lot.
In the second trade your side is worth almost the same, but the banana is worth 2 nons + green toxic, so it is overpay on their side too. Both pets they're offering tend to go for underpay, so it's up to you how you personally value them. Personally I'd go with the banana trade as it seems to getting better offers than the zebra.

[kkspecial4]

I get a lot of offers for this pet....
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76553879&userid=651521&signature=cdEOggTWspaqAGLy9kw8YQ
Is this fair on both sides?

There's also this one as well

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76554547&userid=651521&signature=UrO7kPeTmRofs-D55UIepA

Trade 01:

Unfair to the Winged Blood Dog by roughly 2 Mid Advents.
The Commons/Uncommons on the top side do not make up the difference.

Grinner = 2 Mid Advents + 1 Early 2009 Rare
2017 Store Pet = 1 Mid 2010 Rare

Winged Blood Dog = 4 Mid Advents

Trade 02:

Unfair to the Winged Blood Dog by roughly 2 2009 Rares.
1 Mid Advent = 6-8 2009 Rares
The 2 Uncommons do not help cover the difference.

4 2009 Rares
Scarf PPS = 3 Mid Advents

Winged Blood Dog = 4 Mid Advents

[averys]

(Sorry for posting again so soon!) Is this fair?
x

[the]

(Sorry for posting again so soon!) Is this fair?
x

They're overpaying a lot. Your side is only worth 6 rares '09