The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[snowdrake]

clicky!!

click again c:

are these two trades fair? thank you so much in advance, i'm rlly not sure what to do!!

trade #1: your store pet is worth a late 09 rare while their's is worth a mid 10 rare. the butterfly wolf is a re-release from 2012 and doesn't fill the gap. unfair to you.


trade #2: their blue flower dog is worth 7-8 mixed 09 rares while your side is worth roughly 7 09 rares and a 10 rare. I'd say it's fair c:

[ElementalInsanity]

clicky!!

click again c:

are these two trades fair? thank you so much in advance, i'm rlly not sure what to do!!

For the first one a 2015 store pet= A late o9 rare.
A 2017 is worth a mid 2010. The other rare doesn’t quite make up the gap. It’ll also depend on how you value that gap to what they should replace it with. ^^

On the second trade, while the 2012 store pet is not currently a list I personally would hold onto it as there may be discussion for it to go into the advent list. ^^
At current values I counted about 7 o9 rares which would be fair for a tier 7 advent.

[Emi_]

Is this a fair trade? Not super sure what these items are worth.

[Redpanda]

Even though it’s not fair would you personally take a Non + Sorb for the Coontail? No one seems to want to give the full 2 nons
;-;

[snowdrake]

still need help with these <3

I'm so unsure about this one ;A;
I've just recently returned from a small break from CS and store listies have apparently grown a lot in demand.
I don't know if this is anywhere near fair to me demand wise? how much are my pets going for on average? I don't care much about the timberwolf's value, since I am pretty sure I know where to value it at. I'd highly appreciate any answers!

got another offer! I feel like this one is better than the first offer, but I'm still not sure if it's entirely fair ;v;

----------

Even though it’s not fair would you personally take a Non + Sorb for the Coontail? No one seems to want to give the full 2 nons
;-;

honestly I'd wait. the coontail has a weird thing going on with its demand. I remember it being low on demand, only to suddenly jump up and getting overpay. it might really be worth it to wait c:

[Redpanda]

Thank you both ^^

[bughead]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=76541713&userid=947336&signature=3r6Isaa9aBwDsJZh9-hvfg

[the]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=76541713&userid=947336&signature=3r6Isaa9aBwDsJZh9-hvfg

Very unfair to you. Their side is worth a rare '15.

[JJdiner]

ummm?? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76527746&userid=760178&signature=yhOVlaMQx4m_sTcdxjBeiQ I really don't see this being fair...

38-50 09 rares | (6 MA)
49.5-50.5 + the '12 rares + the items so this is fair without the items. idk the exact price of the items, but since this is borderline fair to overpay, i would say the items make it overpay

[snowdrake]

ummm?? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76527746&userid=760178&signature=yhOVlaMQx4m_sTcdxjBeiQ I really don't see this being fair...

38-50 09 rares | (6 MA)
49.5-50.5 + the '12 rares + the items so this is fair without the items. idk the exact price of the items, but since this is borderline fair to overpay, i would say the items make it overpay

the skull rat is worth between 36 - 48 09 rares (or 6 mid advents), the quantity side is worth about 49.5 09 rares not counting the demand of the malk dragon. the quantity side is overpaying, not only rarity wise but also demand wise, since list rats are especially hard to trade off and quantity store pets can go for a lot compared to their actual worth nowadays.

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=76541713&userid=947336&signature=3r6Isaa9aBwDsJZh9-hvfg

Very unfair to you. Their side is worth a rare '15.

agreed. the uncommon alone is overpay.