The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Icomeinpiece]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76447065

Is this fair or would I be overpaying? ;;

Wrong link

[narvi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76447065

Is this fair or would I be overpaying? ;;

Wrong link

edited it already, sorry ^^

[JJdiner]

Trade 1
^^how would i make this one more fair for both sides?

Trade 2 how fair is this?

Trade 3 How about this one?

Trade 4 what is the difference in fairness between the two sides?
thank you!!

[Redpanda]

Is this fair? Personal opinions?

[sinpai]

Hello!! trades/viewtrade.php?id=76442241&userid=298757&signature=62epM2VjMrg26Ry3hRXOfQ
Is this fair? Thanks in advance :)

Unfair to you
The pets don't add up to yours

[Silver Pandorica]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76447136&userid=881527&signature=nbbj0DbEAu0HwXzTPcrRHA

Opinions please? I dont know which is worth more with the demand

It would be unfair to them, since their store pet is a year older. They would be overpaying.

I was once told that my lion has list demand. Is their pet the same?

Mm, I’ve never seen that lion go for lists. The August PPS Lion does, but this is just a regular store pet, no list value. It goes for fair trades.

[Mya.]

I feel like they're asking for too much for a low Advent list, but I dunno

Click

My side:
Ten '10 uncommons
Two '10 rares
One '10 very rare
Two T1 advents
Two '12 rares
and one '13 uncommon

Their side:
One Tier9 Advent.
------
How can they make it fair?

[Thovatos]

I feel like they're asking for too much for a low Advent list, but I dunno

Click

My side:
Ten '10 uncommons
Two '10 rares
One '10 very rare
Two T1 advents
Two '12 rares
and one '13 uncommon

Their side:
One Tier9 Advent.
------
How can they make it fair?

Before I do the math on this, I just want you to remember, the 2010 uncommon add up to 2010 rares, that then have to become 09 rares to make the conversion right for the listie. Just wanted to say this, because I know it looks like a lot, but it takes 4 2010 uncommons to make a 2009 rare if you use the 2:1 ratio.

Math:

Their side:
A T9 advent is worth 8-9 09 rares.

total worth= 8-9 09 rares.


Your side:

10 2010 uncommons -> 09 rares= 2 09 rares and a 2010 rare left over with the 2:1 ratio used.

+ 1 2010 rare to the leftover 2010 rare, and that = another 09 rare. Your side is currently 3 09 rares.

+T1 Advent= 3-4 09 rares. Your side now adds up to 6-7 09 rares

+T1 Advent= 3-4 09 rares. Your side is now worth up to 9-10 09 rares.


You would now be overpaying by everything else, such as the 2012 rabbit, the 2013 rat/weasel and the VR non-listed Bun.


However!! If they use the 4:1 uncommon ratio to rares, you would be about right or possibly even under for their T9 advent. Most people, for what I gather, use the 4:1 ratio when it comes to older pets, but not so much the newer (2011-), so I would say this is fair on then, but what you choose to decide it up to you. Personally, I wouldn't mind this trade up, because I'd rather have higher advents, than lower ones, but not so much mainlist pets, as having a decently worth group of Advents that are above tier 3 can be nice when trading, more-so than lower advents, but that's just me preferences.

[lordramen]

how fair are all of these demand wise?
1
2
3

[kkspecial4]

Is this fair or would I be overpaying? ;;

Rarity wise this trade is only unfair to the top by 1 2009 Uncommon.
However older Store pets can fetch a little more than their worth depending on your trading partner and how they value them.
As demand is user based it is up to you on where you value them.

Pink Balloon Bun = Tier 6 Advent = 6-7 2009 Rares + 1 2009 Uncommon

2013 Store Pets = 1 Early 2009 Rare each

Total Bottom Side Worth: 6 2009 Rares

is this fair demand wise?
what about this?

Trade 01:

Demand is user based and varies from player to player.
Personally I have not seen too much demand for the PPS Coccoon but again as it is user based it varies.

C$ side is overpaying - 90 C$ is worth a Tier 8 Advent

Mid 2009 Rare/Very Rare = 40-45 C$
*Correction - I forgot the Cocoon was an Advent List - so it is still overpay, just not by as much.

PPS Cocoon = Tier 5 Advent = 75 C$

Trade 02:

Rarity wise the 2012 Store Pet is overpaying - demand is up to you.

2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares

2013 Store Pet (Kitsune) = 1 Early 2009 Rare

I know that demand wise the entire Kitsune set can fetch a Low/Mid Advent, however on a single Kitusne I’m not too sure on their demand but I’m assuming with demand they can fetch 1-2 2009 Rares, maybe more.