The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[popping star]

Ty Chunks! Imma get another opinion to be sure

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76385998&userid=937734&signature=BraGYY-DbWfIfTvNLao8sg

Scourage/ warrior cats in general have a good demand and ARE worth more than an 09 rare. Because many people want them, they trade more than its actually worth (some people). And so, I personally think its fair. Saying that the 2013 store pets is worth 1 09 rare+ '10 rare

Scourge isn't worth an '09 rare or more. It is only worth a 2010 uncommon due to extended release.
It gets valued at a '09 rare or more due to demand.

[Redpanda]

How could I make this fair?

[Silitha]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76387428&userid=407937&signature=dCFuqSwI0u94DDp6gMZmIQ

Fair?

[nobxdy]

How could I make this fair?

This trade is already fair according to the 3 month rule, the dog is originally from July 2009, and the horse was an extended release from '08 to May '09. ^^

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76387428&userid=407937&signature=dCFuqSwI0u94DDp6gMZmIQ

Fair?

It looks unfair to you because of the large date gap.

[christina30]

could i please have an opinion on this Thank you
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76382089&userid=915619&signature=k8aNizDyO84GFT1yuAv8IQ

and this please
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76388227&userid=915619&signature=TEv0D1xuXXYcqjKmrk_ElQ
Thank you

[Lopez]

bamp
Is this fair?
Please edit if not c:

[kittykore]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76388197&userid=671390&signature=zA97VENsShIB7buRBMnSwg

Fair? Thank you!

[JessKnight]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76388414&userid=904849&signature=mm7M9-MYp_8Hk77rbsSa5g

I'm fairly new to fully getting prices down, so I went along with another thread I found, but I wanted some extra opinions on if the pricing is too low or anything. Everything is Uncommon and Common, There were about 3 from 2018 and 9 from 2017 which is why the price only ended up with 20 C$ (18 but I really liked a few)

I mostly wanna make sure I'm not under- or overcharging myself since I'm still super new to this

EDIT: We worked it all out and it ended up well!

[Minibug ♡]

Are these fair? Tysm for any help!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76382489&userid=925477&signature=VT6U2S5J3bybjmDpx9q8Pw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76382088&userid=925477&signature=3DDtCG4DC4TbJkGnEzoD4Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76383068&userid=925477&signature=L8X7WchzJE3n9C4Wmk7yqg

[rainbowwrowell]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76388543&userid=814755&signature=RZ1HE_rfhokFPeGdu3QqdA