The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[coppercanary]

Is this a fair trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76361993&userid=894560&signature=EOaJwfv5NRI-cpEznFw3ZA

That’s fair. '17 uncommons are worth '18 rares.

Could I have some advice on this trade please? I’m pretty sure it’s unfair to me but I’d just like to check.

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

Would this be fair if I took away one of the 2011 store pets?

[the]

Would this be fair if I took away one of the 2011 store pets?

Unfair to them. Their side is worth roughly 13 rares '09 and the tinsel lion is worth 5-6 rares '09.
'11 store pet = 2 rares '09 + rare '10, so the trade would still be unfair to them.

[mossmuttz]

Is this a fair trade?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76361993&userid=894560&signature=EOaJwfv5NRI-cpEznFw3ZA

2 2017 uncommons = 1 2018 Rare, so on so fourth. So unfair to you by a 2017 uncommon.
Correct me if I’m wrong oops

[averys]

Fair?

Thanks!

[nobxdy]

Fair?

Thanks!

Their dog is worth about a mid-late '09 rare due to extended release (originally from 2008), and your store pet is worth a late 2009 rare. I'd say this is about fair. ^^

[averys]

Fair?

Thanks!

Their dog is worth about a mid-late '09 rare due to extended release (originally from 2008), and your store pet is worth a late 2009 rare. I'd say this is about fair. ^^

Alright, thanks! Have a nice day/night.

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

Would this be fair if I took away one of the 2011 store pets?

Unfair to them. Their side is worth roughly 13 rares '09 and the tinsel lion is worth 5-6 rares '09.
'11 store pet = 2 rares '09 + rare '10, so the trade would still be unfair to them.

Would it be more fair if I took 2 of them away?

[magician,]

Which One Of These Offers Is The Best One To Take?
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=76359927&userid=919360&signature=omCXllcJr1WLzVWmjvzyuw
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=76353715&userid=919360&signature=Vnmd2AuFoc_-_3QJIXKN5g
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=76352887&userid=919360&signature=n8URxyASUurZVueCE-BUcg
4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=76363745&userid=919360&signature=8xNEswE3TG5gFEMIPLJlMA

[nobxdy]

Which One Of These Offers Is The Best One To Take?
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=76359927&userid=919360&signature=omCXllcJr1WLzVWmjvzyuw
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=76353715&userid=919360&signature=Vnmd2AuFoc_-_3QJIXKN5g
3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=76352887&userid=919360&signature=n8URxyASUurZVueCE-BUcg

The second trade is worth the most out of all of them, and they're even overpaying. ^^