The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[zero.two]

Which one is better? and which would you choose?
1
2

I'd take the second one, personally. The zebras and the cucumber don't have the best demand, but the Joker can go for 1-2 nons

[IWanaBeFriendsWithYa]

Which one is better? and which would you choose?
1
2

both are very very close!! But if i were personally offered these, i would definitely go with the second one!
Why?
Ill tell you.
Im in a good mood I'm sorry
So, the both have non dogs
The both have zebras
however, the second one has the OMGSR rarity, which is more sought out. if i were to get a zebra, i would want the OMGSR, so it'll be easier to trade off.
then the top trade you have the cucumber, usually worth 2 nons and a green toxic HOWEVER because it has incredibly poor demand, its worth a non...but no one really pays a non for it
whereas the other one has a JOKER DOG! Great demand Amazing look. worth about a non with good demand, could also get a bit more if you're patient! (Talking from experience!) I've even seen a couple of players in the last week offered a coontail (2 nons) for their joker.

than you have the extra pet on the top trade. now i PERSONALLY think that the demand and heartache and effort to own low demand pets isn't worth the extra pet.

what i mean is, if you can get "a little bit extra" for all the great pets on trade number 2, it would most certainly add up to over the UR Foals worth, i would say.

feel free to get an opinion though!!
or offer with me for a dogtag & 2 speckled rats?:(

[TomBoyCOOLCH13]

I was hoping to get help with checking the fairness of this trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76321210&userid=910473&signature=BRM8_r0F0eAqXfuIDmm4_Q

Along with this offer as well, it has a fair bit of pets involved so fair warning

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76321138&userid=910473&signature=sh8D8OC9GHjfaYPqg_5Syg

Thank you so much for the help!

Trade 01:

Overall this is pretty fair - if not slight underpay depending on where you value the Malk Dragon and the Chesire.

Scarf PPS = Low September List = 3 Mid Advents = 19-23 2009 Rares

Brown Red-String Horse = Tier 4 Advent = 5-6 2009 Rares
Yellow/Brown Cookie = Tier 7 Advent = 7-8 2009 Rares
Green Malk Dragon = 1 Late 2009 Rare (with demand 2-3 2009 Rares)
Chesire Cat = 2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares (with demand - 1 Low/Mid Advent = 4-8 2009 Rares)

Bottom Total Worth: 17-23 2009 Rares
^Valuing the Chesire at 1 Low/Mid Advent and the Green Malk Dragon at 1 2009 Rare

Trade 02:

Unfair to the bottom of the trade, by roughly 5 2009 Rares + 1 2010 Rare.

5 2009 Rares
Light Leopard = 2 Mid Advents + 1 2009 Rare = 14-16 2009 Rares
2 2017 Store Pets = 2 Mid 2010 Rares = 1 Mid 2009 Rare
5 2018 Store Pets = 5 Late 2010 Rares = 2 Late 2009 Rares + 1 Late 2010 Rare
Pavlova Dessert = 1 Early 2010 Rare
1 2011 Rare
1 2015 Rare
1 2017 Rare

Orange Spotted October = 2008 Very Rare = 2 2009 Rares + 1 2010 Rare
Yellow/Brown Cookie = Tier 7 Advent = 7-8 2009 Rares
Pink Sorren B'day Dog = 1 Early 2009 Rare
Bobtailed Black 2nd Gen = 2008 Rare - extended release = 1 Mid 2009 Rare
Hoshiko Ember Dog = 1 Mid 2009 Rare
Blue Sortic/Soxic = 1 Late 2009 Rare
Yellow Sortic/Soxic = 1 Late 2009 Rare
Tricolour Grey 2nd Gen = 2009 Rare - extended release = 1 Mid 2010 Rare
Green Malk Dragon = 1 Late 2009 Rare (with demand 2-3 2009 Rares)
Grey Yin-yang = 1 Late 2009 Rare
Feather Lucy/Arctic = 1 Early 2010 Rare
Malk Striped Golden Koi = 1 Early 2010 Rare
Pumpkin Dog = 1 Late 2010 Rare
2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares
Three-tailed Green Pastel = 2008 Rare = 2 2009 Rares
Malk Spotted leopard Appaloosa Horse = 2009 Very Rare = 2 2009 Rares
Chesire Cat = 2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares (with demand - 1 Low/Mid Advent = 4-8 2009 Rares)

Total Top Worth: 23-26 2009 Rares + 1 2011 Rare + 1 2015 Rare + 1 2017 Rare

Total Bottom Worth: 28.5-33.5 2009 Rares (28-33 2009 Rares + 1 2010 Rare)
^Valuing the Chesire at 1 Low/Mid Advent and the Green Malk Dragon at 1 2009 Rare

thank you so so much for the specific help! this is incredibly useful info thank you thank you!

[KissedByABird]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76324536&userid=342936&signature=RLPQxp_Dhshi8bDpZPCtlg
thank you in advance for your help

[Chunks5581]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76326792&userid=942968&signature=_bLNmmPUlXtndq7wHpEtMg personally what do you value the brown slepnir at? Is this fair to me?

[Kina202]

fair? boop tysm in advance! :3

[Mya.]

Is this fair?

Demand wise and how easy/hard it is to trade off a sorbet vs my other pets.

Click

There's the mainlist rat, 2 September lists, dark leopard & Halloween cat, and the Advent list, which is the bunny. And a few other decently older rares+

[zero.two]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76326792&userid=942968&signature=_bLNmmPUlXtndq7wHpEtMg personally what do you value the brown slepnir at? Is this fair to me?

This is extremely unfair to you. The spotted tribal is a below gap main list, while the slepnir's are only a low sept and advent

[cloven]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76326851&userid=919435&signature=M2SrA_A_0VLnM6FdO7Zgfw
I’m not good at item rarities— can someone please help me know what to add or subtract

[IWanaBeFriendsWithYa]

Is this fair?

Demand wise and how easy/hard it is to trade off a sorbet vs my other pets.

Click

It looks like a pretty decent offer in my eyes! Im not great with multiple list trades unless were dealing with nons, but obviously you have a high september, a couple of mid advents, a low main list and a few rares there! if it didn't involve the dragon cat i would say AMAZING ! alas, he is there. and he is incredibly popular as you're probably aware of! I've seen a lot of offers for him including mid september lists so I'm valuing him at that.
now, it is still quite big overpay on the Sorbet's half. sorbs are actually quite popular i believe. they go for their value for sure! plus the rat is very difficult to get its worth.

i would personally take it

(I mean, if i had the dragon cat i wouldn't give him up for the world.....again...im sorry baby)

but yes it does seem like overpay, do 100% get a second opinion though as these trades aren't my strong point!