The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[IWanaBeFriendsWithYa]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76324637&userid=830538&signature=eiavpHNvUMrv9K0yjSUG5Q
This is a bid on my auction! I don’t think it’s fair, but I would like some second opinions! Thanks in advance!

It is fair. 2 09' rares = an 09' VR

Agreed, the 2 ponies are payment enough, everything else its overpay. the Draft horses don't have any special demand that i am aware of

[zero.two]

I've been asking for two days now and I really don't want to keep them waiting any longer <3 Could I please get some thoughts on this trade? Is it fair to both sides?
bop

I honestly have no idea. My best guess would be to value every item as an uncommon of the same year and go from there.

Okie dokie, thank you. I just know some items are special/worth more than others, and I wasn't sure if any of these were highly valued.

Could I have a second opinion, perhaps?

The only items with any special rarity are "Eros" and the pumpkin set. The set is worth an early 09' rare/vr and Eros is worth a late 09' rare / vr

[Redpanda]

Which one is better? and which would you choose?
1
2

[cyanic]

i apologize for asking so much recently, but is this fair? i appreciate any help <3

edit; this too?

[KissedByABird]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76324536&userid=342936&signature=RLPQxp_Dhshi8bDpZPCtlg
thank you in advance for your help

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

Hi, I have no idea what the UR cat is worth, but it this fair?

Edit, they changed it, I really need help! Thank you

The spotted tribal is a tier below the main gap while the ur ice cat side doesn't even equal a sorbet. Personally, with patience, I've seen the spotted tribal go for 1.5 - 2 sorbets. So I would say unfair to the tribal ^

Second opinion??

[Redpanda]

Which one is better? and which would you choose?
1
2

[*space*]

i apologize for asking so much recently, but is this fair? i appreciate any help <3

edit; this too?

Not sure about the second one, but I think the first trade is unfair to the sitting cat side. The other side needs older pets.

[TomBoyCOOLCH13]

I was hoping to get help with checking the fairness of this trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76321210&userid=910473&signature=BRM8_r0F0eAqXfuIDmm4_Q

Along with this offer as well, it has a fair bit of pets involved so fair warning

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76321138&userid=910473&signature=sh8D8OC9GHjfaYPqg_5Syg

Thank you so much for the help!

[kkspecial4]

I was hoping to get help with checking the fairness of this trade?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76321210&userid=910473&signature=BRM8_r0F0eAqXfuIDmm4_Q

Along with this offer as well, it has a fair bit of pets involved so fair warning

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76321138&userid=910473&signature=sh8D8OC9GHjfaYPqg_5Syg

Thank you so much for the help!

Trade 01:

Overall this is pretty fair - if not slight underpay depending on where you value the Malk Dragon and the Chesire.

Scarf PPS = Low September List = 3 Mid Advents = 19-23 2009 Rares

Brown Red-String Horse = Tier 4 Advent = 5-6 2009 Rares
Yellow/Brown Cookie = Tier 7 Advent = 7-8 2009 Rares
Green Malk Dragon = 1 Late 2009 Rare (with demand 2-3 2009 Rares)
Chesire Cat = 2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares (with demand - 1 Low/Mid Advent = 4-8 2009 Rares)

Bottom Total Worth: 17-23 2009 Rares
^Valuing the Chesire at 1 Low/Mid Advent and the Green Malk Dragon at 1 2009 Rare

Trade 02:

Unfair to the bottom of the trade, by roughly 5 2009 Rares + 1 2010 Rare.

5 2009 Rares
Light Leopard = 2 Mid Advents + 1 2009 Rare = 14-16 2009 Rares
2 2017 Store Pets = 2 Mid 2010 Rares = 1 Mid 2009 Rare
5 2018 Store Pets = 5 Late 2010 Rares = 2 Late 2009 Rares + 1 Late 2010 Rare
Pavlova Dessert = 1 Early 2010 Rare
1 2011 Rare
1 2015 Rare
1 2017 Rare

Orange Spotted October = 2008 Very Rare = 2 2009 Rares + 1 2010 Rare
Yellow/Brown Cookie = Tier 7 Advent = 7-8 2009 Rares
Pink Sorren B'day Dog = 1 Early 2009 Rare
Bobtailed Black 2nd Gen = 2008 Rare - extended release = 1 Mid 2009 Rare
Hoshiko Ember Dog = 1 Mid 2009 Rare
Blue Sortic/Soxic = 1 Late 2009 Rare
Yellow Sortic/Soxic = 1 Late 2009 Rare
Tricolour Grey 2nd Gen = 2009 Rare - extended release = 1 Mid 2010 Rare
Green Malk Dragon = 1 Late 2009 Rare (with demand 2-3 2009 Rares)
Grey Yin-yang = 1 Late 2009 Rare
Feather Lucy/Arctic = 1 Early 2010 Rare
Malk Striped Golden Koi = 1 Early 2010 Rare
Pumpkin Dog = 1 Late 2010 Rare
2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares
Three-tailed Green Pastel = 2008 Rare = 2 2009 Rares
Malk Spotted leopard Appaloosa Horse = 2009 Very Rare = 2 2009 Rares
Chesire Cat = 2012 Store Pet = 2 2009 Rares (with demand - 1 Low/Mid Advent = 4-8 2009 Rares)

Total Top Worth: 23-26 2009 Rares + 1 2011 Rare + 1 2015 Rare + 1 2017 Rare

Total Bottom Worth: 28.5-33.5 2009 Rares (28-33 2009 Rares + 1 2010 Rare)
^Valuing the Chesire at 1 Low/Mid Advent and the Green Malk Dragon at 1 2009 Rare