The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[MOVED !!!]

I've got two offers on this pet, please help. 😵
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960645&userid=437421&signature=xEWsuw-QWgjTL82CtdCjVQ

Or

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75955996&userid=437421&signature=niyaucx-qwXguBKWwf4bag

A 2013 storepet = early 09' rare, the second is the fairest. (pet popularity and quantity wise)
edit; sorry, forgot to add(i'm tired), the 1st would be overpay, but the pets aren't easy to trade off
(I'd be extremely surprised if you got a 2013 storepet with special demand for lower-demanded species
like horses and rats...Meanwhile on the 2nd trade, there is a 09' rare, which is one of the popular species
(sitting cat) and a lot of other good rares !! )

[nobxdy]

I've got two offers on this pet, please help. 😵
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960645&userid=437421&signature=xEWsuw-QWgjTL82CtdCjVQ

Or

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75955996&userid=437421&signature=niyaucx-qwXguBKWwf4bag

I'd take the second

Please stop giving false advice. As the Thread Rules states, If you don't know then don't answer, and explain why a trade is fair/unfair. Please read the rules on the first page.

The first trade is overpaying more than the second trade. The first trade is worth over 3 '09 rares, the second one is only worth an '09 rare + '10 rare.

[Twisted Wolf]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75961364&userid=936356&signature=BhdzaHlHgifggreV37wxeg

[MOVED !!!]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75961364&userid=936356&signature=BhdzaHlHgifggreV37wxeg

Yes, like said above, it is worth a 10' rare.

[nobxdy]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75961364&userid=936356&signature=BhdzaHlHgifggreV37wxeg

Unfair to them. Your PPS is worth a late 2010 rare, they're offering an early 2010 rare.

[Twisted Wolf]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75961364&userid=936356&signature=BhdzaHlHgifggreV37wxeg

Unfair to them. Your PPS is worth a late 2010 rare, they're offering an early 2010 rare.

It's what they offered me but I'll try make it fairer ^^

Is this fair by any chance?? Idk xD
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75961426&userid=936356&signature=cIdHk94tIht-ajQsMZWzpQ

[SkunkSmell]

Is this fair by any chance?? Idk xD
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75961426&userid=936356&signature=cIdHk94tIht-ajQsMZWzpQ

No. Unfair to you. The pet is worth no less than a 2010 rare.

[Twisted Wolf]

How's this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75961484&userid=936356&signature=x_qRloQuBDsE_LGQ9mUSwA
Is that fair? Idk the info I was given about this was:
'2 2011' rares
4 2012 rares
6 2013 rares
^ these would be best in my opinion
8 2014 rares
10 2015 rares
12 2016 rares
14 2017 rares
18 2018 rares.'

[SkunkSmell]

How's this?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75961484&userid=936356&signature=x_qRloQuBDsE_LGQ9mUSwA
Is that fair? Idk the info I was given about this was:
'2 2011' rares
4 2012 rares
6 2013 rares
^ these would be best in my opinion
8 2014 rares
10 2015 rares
12 2016 rares
14 2017 rares
18 2018 rares.'

Unfair to you, like I said, there rares must add up to a 2010 rare.

[Twisted Wolf]

Oki doki ^^
It's changed btw