The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lopez]

Hello! I'd like an opinion on this trade please. Is it fair, and if not, what would they need to add?

Thanks in advance!!

[Skyhawk]

hi - haven't been on in a while so not sure about this trade
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76160638&userid=381655&signature=cECg4dwcTj2WEPfFRBnryQ
any help is appreciated!

[SolarSam]

Is this fair? Thank you in advance!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76160958&userid=836917&signature=HdSPEwZXUQidH07zzPJZiQ

[Seall]

Hey guys, is this trade fair?: trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161066&userid=711109&signature=efEGuS2o3NlMOe0Gh0rSdg

thanks! ^-^

[freya.mikaelson]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161212&userid=412178&signature=hhqT_ubkLbXPbmd6w1UmVA

Help please! Thanks

Edit: and this too
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161420&userid=412178&signature=8xGy6nD21_izSE_5z1onsA

[Oramis]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161408&userid=557594&signature=VRJd1qIc6E4bR6V7vOlXrA

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161212&userid=412178&signature=hhqT_ubkLbXPbmd6w1UmVA

Help please! Thanks :)

Edit: and this too
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161420&userid=412178&signature=8xGy6nD21_izSE_5z1onsA

The second trade is slightly unfair to the purple batdog as it's worth 6.5 mid advents.
Your side is worth 5.5 mid advents.

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161212&userid=412178&signature=hhqT_ubkLbXPbmd6w1UmVA

Help please! Thanks :)

Edit: and this too
trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161420&userid=412178&signature=8xGy6nD21_izSE_5z1onsA

They're offering you a rose PPS which is jsut at the bottom of the 'The rarest list'.
However. You're being asked to give 3 tier 7 pets (dark grey tag husky+purple heart/husky+Yellow/brown cookie) A tier 1 spider wing wolf+ tier 5 red android wolf
The rest add up to 21 09' rares. However I may be wrong ebcaus my math is so bad-

The red rose pps is worth 67-88 '09 rares.
The bottom of the trade adds up to 59 '09 rares at most, so it's unfair to the rose pps by rarity.
Quantity has a value of its own, so it's up to the traders how high they value the quantity.

[Miekiepiekie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76056153&userid=833059&signature=wBp2INQDz56rmXEhR0-Btg

Is this one fair? If its not, how can i make it fair?
I have no idea how much a storepet is worth

[Topsy Turvey]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76161408&userid=557594&signature=VRJd1qIc6E4bR6V7vOlXrA

Usually people never accept lower rarity pets for rares but fi you are one of the people who do accept lower rarity pets here -
Its increadibly unfair ot you because only about 3-4 pets on their side are older than the ares you have.
In my opinion they barely add up to what they want from you! ^^

I disagree on some parts, I don't think it's too unfair at all as long as my math is right. From what I know (please correct me if I'm wrong) a 2011 uncommon would be worth a 2013 rare and a 2013 rare is worth 2 2014 rares which leaves the rest of the quantity for the last 2014 rare. Personally I think this is about fair or ever so slightly unfair to them however please get another opinion to make sure my math is right c: