The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76112087&userid=830538&signature=UZLuAxIuBtjY3QPP1NpDhQ

I'm clueless on items...

1 2018 Rare = 4 2018 Uncommons = 2 2017 Uncommons = 1 2016 Uncommon
Pet Side Total Worth: 3 2016 Uncommons (or 1 2015 Uncommon + 1 2016 Uncommon)

Wolf Plushie = Christmas 2015 = 2015 Uncommon
Golden Retriever Plushie = Christmas 2015 = 2015 Uncommon
Item Side Total Worth: 2 2015 Uncommons (or 1 2014 Uncommon)

Seeing as I am on the other side of this trade though I would get a second opinion ♥

Since they were free items, I honestly value them as a 2015 common each. A 2018 rare is worth a 2015 common, so they'd be overpaying by a 2018 rare (if that's how you were to value them).

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76100599&userid=644570&signature=ph_T7KvFEzDmsmjgeWDxgQ

is this fair??

They're overpaying. Just the Butterfly Wolf would be fair for the Lion according to the 3 month rule. (:

[kkspecial4]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76100599&userid=644570&signature=ph_T7KvFEzDmsmjgeWDxgQ

is this fair??

Overpay on the top side.

The 2014 Common Butterfly Wolf would be a fair swap for the 2014 Common Lion as they are within the three month rule.
The items are not necessary and make it overpay.

[;Syndromed Sickness;]

Is this fair?

[Swerenity]

Fair demand wise? (I value it at a sorbet)

[nobxdy]

Is this fair?

Unfair to them. The 2010 uncommons are worth a lot more than your 2013 rare. ^^

Fair demand wise? (I value it at a sorbet)

Since you value the BMD at a Sorbet, this is unfair to you. Their side is only worth a Mid September List. ^^

[kkspecial4]

Is this fair?

Unfair to them. The 2010 uncommons are worth a lot more than your 2013 rare. ^^

I agree ^^

1 2013 Rare = 4 2013 Uncommons = 2 2012 Uncommons = 1 2011 Uncommon

The 2011 Uncommon dog would be a fair swap so everything else is overpay.

[*space*]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76112087&userid=830538&signature=UZLuAxIuBtjY3QPP1NpDhQ

I'm clueless on items...

Thanks to everyone that's already replied! Any other opinions? I have no idea what these items are worth sooooo...

[LazyRainwing]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76104207&userid=651521&signature=d4UzNwC9S1h1fPfVa0mO6w

hey guys!! Im trying to find what is fair the the pps dragon cat!!! and i got this offer?? i just need help to find its worth before i trade...

[flora]

xxx was this trade really bad for me, even considering that the july pps has "bad" demand? ;n; would like to know for future reference and to learn from it.

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76104207&userid=651521&signature=d4UzNwC9S1h1fPfVa0mO6w

hey guys!! Im trying to find what is fair the the pps dragon cat!!! and i got this offer?? i just need help to find its worth before i trade...

The PPS Dragon Cat goes for a low-mid advent, so I'd say you're overpaying massively. Just your Blue Snowflake Scarfdog would be fine for it.