The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[the]

valuing the peach and the bee where they're placed on the list, is this fair? if the c$ wasn't in the trade, what pets could be used to fill the gap between the bee and the peach? thank you! ❤

The UR peach doesn't have a set value, it's worth between the UR holly dog to a non and the bee is worth 2 nons. The gap would be something with a non - UR lion worth, depending how you personally value the peach.

can i get an opinion on this? i was given a few mixed answers so i'd like a few more opinions! i've heard the coontail has bad demand so i'm not sure! =))

Slighty unfair to you. Your side is worth 3 nons/9 sorbets and their UR cat is worth 2 nons + 2 sorbets or just 8 sorbets.

[~Loki~]

How much is my side worth?

[sæter]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76042372&userid=845505&signature=CY8ItOrJ5BKC8nE7ofjvig

Would like both rarity and demand opinions

Hi!
Rarity-wise, the trade would be overpay on their side.
Your side: 1 Non (which is worth 3 Sorbets)
Their side: Nick Unicorn, UR Rat, '09 Rare, '15 Rare
A Nick Unicorn is worth 2 Sorbets + a Red Rose. A UR Rat is worth 1 Sorbet + a Red X PPS. Basically, their side is worth 1 Non + a Red Rose + a Red X PPS (+ an '09 rare and a '15 Rare). That would make their side be overpay by a Red X PPS and a Red Rose.

Demand-wise, however, the pets' values might be different.
UR Rats usually can't even get 1 Sorbet (it took me around 3 months to trade it off, and even then, I still had to accept underpay), and Nick Unicorns are usually hard to trade off as well, due to their poor demand. Both list pets on their side have rather poor demand, so I personally wouldn't take it.

(In conclusion; rarity-wise, they're overpaying by a Red X PPS + a Red Rose.
Demand wise, I wouldn't take the trade due to the poor demand of the Nick Unicorn and UR Rat, as both pets are hard to trade off, and you'll most likely have to accept underpay.)
I'd highly recommend getting a second opinion! ^^

i disagree very strongly. both the nick unicorn and ur rat are incredibly undervalued by the rares list. rarity wise, either of those pets would be over for the non. the list is not fully based on rarity, so to say list-wise=rarity-wise is wrong. "demand" wise, both the ur rat and nick unicorn can swap for a sorb at least with patience and if you find the right people, possibly even more. though it seems like they have terrible demand, there are people who would do that considering rarity. nons can be difficult to trade down as well, so i personally would definitely take it. it's an even better trade if you intend on keeping the pets; they are ultimately paying 2 omgsrs for your average non. i don't think it would be hard to get a non back with both those pets either.

[ordinary people]

What needs to be added to this to make it fair; if it isn't already. Thanks c:

[<InsertName>]

Im not to sure on what the deer 2015 store pets are worth, but i dont think they are worth 3 '09, rares how much should i edit this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76044215&userid=674735&signature=iI0Lc7_Zm-EZ-LrOSFvXnQ

[MOVED !!!]

What needs to be added to this to make it fair; if it isn't already. Thanks c:

Unfair to you, they need to remove everything but the 2010 uncommon, then add 3 2010 uncommons.

Im not to sure on what the deer 2015 store pets are worth, but i dont think they are worth 3 '09, rares how much should i edit this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76044215&userid=674735&signature=iI0Lc7_Zm-EZ-LrOSFvXnQ

A 2015 storepet = late 09' rare.
very unfair to you

[the]

Im not to sure on what the deer 2015 store pets are worth, but i dont think they are worth 3 '09, rares how much should i edit this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76044215&userid=674735&signature=iI0Lc7_Zm-EZ-LrOSFvXnQ

A store pet '15 is worth a late rare '09, so you're overpaying a lot.

[<InsertName>]

Im not to sure on what the deer 2015 store pets are worth, but i dont think they are worth 3 '09, rares how much should i edit this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76044215&userid=674735&signature=iI0Lc7_Zm-EZ-LrOSFvXnQ

A store pet '15 is worth a late rare '09, so you're overpaying a lot.

Okay thanks!

[sparrow;]

Is this fair? Thanks for any help!

[Silverstar]

Is this fair? Thanks for any help!

'12 rare = '10 uc. It's about fair as it's just little over the three months rule. Going by demand, I'd keep the warrior :)