The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[lemonishin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960107&userid=774851&signature=xXWCnTLWekxLfH_YCfAlZw

i dont know what shima goes for but

would you do it?

I'm the other one In the trade seeing if it's fair too !

[ooo]

Okay so I’ve already autoed this bid; boop

What do you think? Was it a good idea to accept? Considering the pickle can get a non?

Hi!
From what I've seen, Demand-wise, the BMD can usually get 1 Sorbet.
Rarity-wise, the UR Pickle is worth 2 Nons + Green/Yellow Toxic. Even though it still has bad demand, it can usually, like you said, get at least a Non. I'm sure that if you're patient, you can probably get 2 Nons!
Despite its good demand, I highly doubt a BMD would be able to get a whole Non.
So, yes, I think it was a good idea to accept. Definitely worth it! ^^

Thank you!

[lemonishin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960107&userid=774851&signature=xXWCnTLWekxLfH_YCfAlZw

i dont know what shima goes for but

would you do it?

I'm the other one In the trade seeing if it's fair too !

[popping star]

Opinions on this bid?
I personally love it as cake dogs are my favorite lists!
I just want to know if it's overall a great trade. ^^

[mynameisbacon]

Fair? I know the shima is high demand but... idk
Also, does anybody know some stuff that people who really want the shima would give for it?

Here's the trade:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960038&userid=936315&signature=nC93Seo1QUUuRHjKAw2L1A

[popping star]

Opinions on this bid?
I personally love it as cake dogs are my favorite lists!
I just want to know if it's overall a great trade. ^^

[M4NICWOLF]

Ia this trade fair?

[popping star]

Ia this trade fair?

Rarity wise, it's unfair to the UR aussie as it's worth 1 non and 1 sorbet.
Demand is up to you.
The aussie typically fetches a non, however, so this could be considered fair even with the advent on your side.

[Skóll]

Could I get some help for this trade here. If it's not fair what can be added or removed? Thank you so much for the help

[Vaal Hazak]

Could I get some help for this trade here. If it's not fair what can be added or removed? Thank you so much for the help

Unfair to you, by 1 - 3 '10 uncommons (depends on how many uncommons you value for a rare of the same year)