The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[This Is Halloween]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75959920&userid=887586&signature=iGzdb_3QT8gGZNforkamuA

Your fish is an 09 re-release which their 16 rare doesn’t add up to. They would have to trade 128 ‘16 rares to make it equivalent to your 2009, though nobody would trade that much quantity.

[ooo]

Okay so I’ve already autoed this bid; boop

What do you think? Was it a good idea to accept? Considering the pickle can get a non?

[FANTASIIIA]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960107&userid=774851&signature=xXWCnTLWekxLfH_YCfAlZw

i dont know what shima goes for but

[TheKwakiutlTribe]

I was running a few auctions, and need help deciding which to choose, thanks to anyone who can help!

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75839539&userid=710778&signature=RjlIj1h6wp9hmXQBlf5nvg Good bid! 8/10 *LEADING BID* 3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75869481&userid=710778&signature=GrdXrAlkOllf79gUqdltBQ ! 8/10 *TIED FOR LEADING* 4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75917277&userid=710778&signature=0rK_8-rNk2evXA3CjqhHpQ 8/10 *TIED FOR LEADING*

[Seasonal]

This is a bid
Is it fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960001&userid=936315&signature=XJQAiFc9eIoNmMC72bGV4A

no. all your pets are rereleases and the dates don't line up, even in the slightest

Please don't give false advice. This is about List Pets, not just dates.

Your side is worth a Tier 5 Advent + a T2 Advent + a T4 Advent, whereas there side is worth a 3 Mid Advents (either T5, T6 or T7), a T4 Advent and 2 Early '09 Rares.
That trade was overpay on their side.

Okay so I’ve already autoed this bid; boop

What do you think? Was it a good idea to accept? Considering the pickle can get a non?

Hi!
From what I've seen, Demand-wise, the BMD can usually get 1 Sorbet.
Rarity-wise, the UR Pickle is worth 2 Nons + Green/Yellow Toxic. Even though it still has bad demand, it can usually, like you said, get at least a Non. I'm sure that if you're patient, you can probably get 2 Nons!
Despite its good demand, I highly doubt a BMD would be able to get a whole Non.
So, yes, I think it was a good idea to accept. Definitely worth it! ^^

[FANTASIIIA]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960107&userid=774851&signature=xXWCnTLWekxLfH_YCfAlZw

i dont know what shima goes for but

would you do it?

[Horror]

is this fair??

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75959829&userid=648479&signature=CFnDgJR0Te-FQhKdxnyWPg

this too

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75960087&userid=648479&signature=lR7-dvQQmeLT3YobHTw4lQ

Onl post your questions once per page. Spamming the thread isn't going to get faster help or make anyone want to help.

1. 2 2010 uncommons = 09 uncommon so they're overpaying slightly
2. Unfair to them as they're offering 2 2010 rares for the worth of 2 2010 uncommons on your side

for pink flop eared september?

Edit;; also this please <3

( sorry for the item question - I’ve seen people ask the same thing on here before and assumed it was okay since I was asking what’s fair for it. My apologies!)

1. Floppy sept = roughly 34-45 09 rares or 5 mid advents and a low advent
Your side adds up to 35-36 09 rares so this could be considered around fair as it's within that range

2. Unfair to them as your side = 1.5 09 rares, their very rare butterfly wolf alone is worth 2 09 rares

[TheKwakiutlTribe]

I was running a few auctions, and need help deciding which to choose, thanks to anyone who can help!

2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75839539&userid=710778&signature=RjlIj1h6wp9hmXQBlf5nvg Good bid! 8/10 *LEADING BID* 3. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75869481&userid=710778&signature=GrdXrAlkOllf79gUqdltBQ ! 8/10 *TIED FOR LEADING* 4. trades/viewtrade.php?id=75917277&userid=710778&signature=0rK_8-rNk2evXA3CjqhHpQ 8/10 *TIED FOR LEADING*

[Light Bringer]

Coontail = UR lion + Purple batdog?
How fair would that be?

[Horror]

Coontail = UR lion + Purple batdog?
How fair would that be?

Ur lion + ur holly = coontail
A sept list doesn't make any difference here so it'd be unfair to the coon if the batdog's the only filler for the lion