The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Fizzy-Pop]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75854519&userid=786237&signature=nPCGoDkIx9iBYWC2QH2ptQ

I missed the event and was trying to get the pets. I don't think this is fair? Are the Macaws that rare?

This very unfair! Your pet is on the list and one macaw are not even worth a tier 1 avent pet. Those Macaws would be worth at least a 2016 uncommon max (if the rarity turns out to be a rare)

[stormsurge0]

Is this fair? Thank you in advance! trades/viewtrade.php?id=75854606&userid=887698&signature=3mg6DzSVK02GNl2c0Fj6VQ

[kalcifer]

Which side is worth more?

We both have a lot of commons and uncommons so don't pay too much attention to them, just consider them as trade fodder. I'm mostly interested in the rares and very rares.

[Aseria Greane]

I am absolutely terrible at judging the fairness of bigger trades so any help would be GREATLY appreciated uvu

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75845395&userid=825697&signature=VGzj0h3SC9rEzqiUQUwNOQ

[stormsurge0]

Is this fair trades/viewtrade.php?id=75854345&userid=925404&signature=Ajr4hAHg5fr31DM52asQVQ

Unfair to you by a lot, just the 2014 uncommon would probably still be overpay on your side

[kimii]

Is this a fair trade?
Non-Coon = UR Dog+Light Pawprint+113 assorted rares?
I'm not experienced enough with rares list pets to know what their side is worth all together.
Thank you for any/all help <3 ^^

I know for sure that wont be fair to you. Just the lowest advent tier goes for a couple of rares and the balloon dog is not even 1/5 the worth of the non coon.

Yeah I assumed it's unfair to me, but I was hoping to know by how much, just so I can get a rough idea of what to be looking for, since they did include a main rares list pet. I always end up replying on this thread with rares list pets so I try to learn while I go as well.
Also, do you mean the balloon dog on the list, or the balloon dog they added? (just to confirm for learning's sake! ^^)

If anyone has a second/more detailed opinion, let me know!

*Edit* Also, is this a fair trade?
2012 store pet = 2010 rare zodiac + 2009 rare wolf?

[ayanami]

could i get some help?
is this fair?

[Silver Pandorica]

How does this look?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75854212&userid=774258&signature=DmVjQxG4Fbjjf4nN_jsp_w

I know some of those items are valuable, but I don’t think they’re that valuable. Plus, I’m hesitant to trade off my lists for items unless they are for very rare ones.

[stormsurge0]

Is this fair? Thank you in advance! trades/viewtrade.php?id=75854606&userid=887698&signature=3mg6DzSVK02GNl2c0Fj6VQ

[Lothlórien]

Could I please get some help with this trade?

Click!
dillydally