The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Endlessechoes]

Hello! I was curious if this and this are fair. Thank you so much in advance to any help/advice! Have a lovely day <33

Also this? Haven't gotten an opinion on any of these yet c:

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75840175&userid=921063&signature=8OcAt4PN2x-I9p1_URjp-A

Help please! Not very good with list trades, thank you to whoever responds!

The UR peas have no list placement, but it typically fetches 1-2 sorbets.
The other side is worth about 1.5 sorbets + a UR apple.
It's up to you if you want to take this.

[Forbidden Gifts!]

Should I accept this trade or not! Plz help and ty for the person who answered I greatly appreciate it!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75840140&userid=942301&signature=1KTZIYYnqfUZEAXeSLS76Q

Currently the macaw eggs are literally “flying” everywhere so I don’t think they will turn out to be rare. So their side is overpaying. The 2 2017 rares would be enough for them but even that could be over trading to them.

[Lothlórien]

Which one of these is best? I have the Cookie Dog, Holly Dog & Christmas Dog. Hoping to get opinions for both demand and rarity.
Thanks!

1

2

3

dillydally

[sour patch.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75839655&userid=920410&signature=8PwNmgIrbax1TW2nPt2WzA

Please help :0

It’s up to you really,
The ceg tends to go for 1 non with demand and the ur Malk as well,
Although the ur cookie has quite bad demand and tends to go for underpay so around a non as well,
Some people value the red Cerberus at 3 nons and that’s what your side is worth with demand, so yet again, up to you c:
Rarity wise though your side is worth 3 nons + a sorbet

Thank you! Can I get a second opinion? trades/viewtrade.php?id=75839655&userid=920410&signature=8PwNmgIrbax1TW2nPt2WzA

[Forbidden Gifts!]

Is This Fair?
Hoping to get opinions for both demand and rarity.
Thanks!

Currently you are still overpaying. The pps scarf pet is above the target. So that would even equal to it. For demand wise you would be over paying to. You have offered advents above the pps scarf dog which consider the demand I I think the pps pet and 1 of the high advents would equal to the dog. The other pets are not needed.

[popping star]

Is This Fair?
Hoping to get opinions for both demand and rarity.
Thanks!

Currently you are still overpaying. The pps scarf pet is above the target. So that would even equal to it. For demand wise you would be over paying to. You have offered advents above the pps scarf dog which consider the demand I I think the pps pet and 1 of the high advents would equal to the dog. The other pets are not needed.

I'm going to disagree here. The pet on the top is the red-x dog, which is on the same tier as the blue rose.
The bottom side is worth slightly over 6 mid advents, so by rarity, it's slightly unfair to the top.
Demand is up to them, but I personally would keep the quantity as they're true dates. That's just my opinion though!

[Lilo.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75839655&userid=920410&signature=8PwNmgIrbax1TW2nPt2WzA

Please help :0
It’s up to you really,
The ceg tends to go for 1 non with demand and the ur Malk as well,
Although the ur cookie has quite bad demand and tends to go for underpay so around a non as well,
Some people value the red Cerberus at 3 nons and that’s what your side is worth with demand, so yet again, up to you c:
Rarity wise though your side is worth 3 nons + a sorbet

Thank you! Can I get a second opinion? trades/viewtrade.php?id=75839655&userid=920410&signature=8PwNmgIrbax1TW2nPt2WzA

FOUND VERDICT previously did,

depends how you value the cerb.
they usually go for 2-3 nons, your side adds up to 3 nons + sorbet (valuing both the ceg and malk at an non)

[Endlessechoes]

Hello! I was curious if this and this are fair. Thank you so much in advance to any help/advice! Have a lovely day <33

Also this? I really need help on these please <3

[Forbidden Gifts!]

Is this fair?

Still need list help *^* it’s been an hour and I feel bad leaving a trade that long already...