The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[ir0nh3art]

Fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=74815683&userid=302090&signature=sN-WlwRa6shOmGYF184osg

This isn't fair either is it?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=74816687&userid=302090&signature=f0tcMWTnQQU2r0I3zRsehw

Fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=74817074&userid=302090&signature=JnI8PqaOCEj-BGDUDgozWw

[then]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=74826417&userid=938744&signature=lDMuynUFRWjuaOO-rIm2rA
Fair? My partner and I are confused! Demand only, please!

[.Wolfskralle.]

Hello everyone. Please, help .__.
*click* and *click*

The second trade is unfair to them. The zebra alone is overpay.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=74823445&userid=932541&signature=PSx0HDDp-r6oIqgs6iKleQ

This is probably the best offer I have been given for my Event pets but do you guys think it's still a good offer?

Considering that the store pets are worth a late 2010 rare each and 20 C$ equal another late 2010 rare their side adds up to more than 3 2010 rares, they are overpaying.

[PinkSugar]

Hello! Can someone please help me out with these trades? Is it fair?
~
#1 Click me!
#2 Click me!
~
A huge thank you to anyone who helps! <3

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=74823445&userid=932541&signature=PSx0HDDp-r6oIqgs6iKleQ

This is probably the best offer I have been given for my Event pets but do you guys think it's still a good offer?

That's an amazing offer! Even if every pet on your side turns rare (unlikely) they have 2 store pets (worth at least '10 rare each), 20C$, and a few other recent rares. That's a lot more than your pets are worth. I don't know what event pets are currently going for with demand, but it is a lot of overpay on their side.

[ooo]

Hello everyone. Please, help .__.
*click* and *click*

As a previous UR Apple owner, I definitely wouldn’t take this trade. Rarity wise, it’s pretty unfair to the apple, but with demand, the apple has very poor demand and is quite difficult to trade off. By itself, it typically trades for quite a bit of underpay, usually not even trading for another below gap mainlist. The grey malk dragon is on the September list, but with its demand, it gets high septembers to low mainlists from what I’ve seen and experienced myself. It’s up to you if you want to accept thoigh.

[Ucanthandleme]

Hello is this fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=74741198&userid=809102&signature=bXgt1mLittkQluFdBdouew

[Neonrift]

Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=74824263

[ooo]

Hello everyone. Please, help .__.
*click* and *click*

As a previous UR Apple owner, I definitely wouldn’t take this trade. Rarity wise, it’s pretty unfair to the apple, but with demand, the apple has very poor demand and is quite difficult to trade off. By itself, it typically trades for quite a bit of underpay, usually not even trading for another below gap mainlist. The grey malk dragon is on the September list, but with its demand, it gets high septembers to low mainlists from what I’ve seen and experienced myself. It’s up to you if you want to accept thoigh.

Hello! Can someone please help me out with this trade? Is it fair?
~
Click me!
~
A huge thank you to anyone who helps! <3

The shima longtail is only an ‘09 rare, worth a couple ‘09 rares itself. However with demand, you shouldn’t have any problem getting a shima for a low-mid advent. I have seen the shima go for low-high September lists many many times though, ranging from grinners all the way up to a purple bat dog. I personally wouldn’t take this trade, but it depends on how you both value the shima and if you think you’d take the time to trade it for more. Rarity wise it’s unfair to you. Demand varies.

[myth;]

Hello is this fair
trades/viewtrade.php?id=74741198&userid=809102&signature=bXgt1mLittkQluFdBdouew

No, 2017 store pets trade for about 25C$ each, so your side is worth 125C$ I do believe.