The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[This Is Halloween]

in an auction! help please Is this fair?

[popping star]

Is this fair??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75637689&userid=893005&signature=S3j6_u2RW6IyCMmhPipwNQ

The UR rat alone would be enough as it typically fetches a sorbet with demand. c:

[kiwifyee<3]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=75674307&userid=859775&signature=D7fIq2WvtmqZZ7ZB7D_Xag
was this fair?

[popping star]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=75674307&userid=859775&signature=D7fIq2WvtmqZZ7ZB7D_Xag
was this fair?

Unfair to the C$ side. 155 C$ is enough for a target dog, which is on the Sept. list.
Your pet is only a tier 7 advent, which makes it worth 85 C$.

[ooo]

Just to be certain, I would love it if I could get a few more opinions. The first trade is an offer of a cucumber for my grinner set. Taking demand into account, is it worth taking the offer & trading the cucumber off for something else? Do cucumbers consistently go for nons, or are they more likely to go for underpay?

The second set of trades is for my complete 2017 store pet set (26 pets). To clarify, 2017 store pets are worth 20-25 C$ each, so the complete set is roughly worth 520-650 C$, which equates to around a low main list. If we were to go by their worth in rares, however, '17 store pets are worth one 2010 rare each, so the set is worth 26 2010 rares, or 13 2009 rares.

Keeping that in mind, these are the offers:
✧ One (7th tier advent + 5 tier advent = 13-15 '09 rares, plus extras)
✧ Two (unsure how many '09 rares this equates to, but presumably less than the other offers)
✧ Three (tenth tier advent = 10 '09 rares, + 9 '09 rares = 19 '09 rares)
✧ Four (seventh tier advent = 7-8 '09 rares, + 8 '09 rares + 1 '08 rares + 120 C$)

Taking all of this into account, the last offer is presumably the best, however - would it be better to sell these pets individually, which would earn around 520-650 C$ total, that could then potentially get me a main list provided I find the right person? I'm so indecisive about these offers haha. ;;

Could I possibly have some advice on these, please? ;A;

The UR cucumber typically goes for about a non, however I wouldn’t say it’s consistent. It depends on how you and your trading partner value it, UR fruits don’t always have the best demand, but you shouldn’t have any trouble getting a non for it if you waited. It’s definitely worth taking, the grinner set is only worth roughly 13 mid advents.

1. I don’t really know what you’re looking for in this store pet trade as you pretty much covered everything yourself, haha. Your math is correct, however most people value them by their rarity and not their C$ value. If you’re looking to get a main list for the set, you’re better off trading the set for C$, although it’s really not easy to get onto the list with C$. Your side with the store pets are worth 13 ‘09 rares, each store pet from the last 3 years is worth a 2010 rare each. The blue Ice swirl advent is worth 7-8 ‘09 rares, the tier 5 is worth 6-7 ‘09 rares, so their side adds up to roughly 14 ‘09 rares total. The extra recent rare and items don’t add much value to the trade. It’s fair.

2. This trade doesn’t add up to anywhere near the value of the store pets.

3. Their side adds up to 19 ‘09 rares, they’re overpaying by a few ‘09 rares rarity wise, and personally this is the best trade out of the three, and I would accept this one.

Okay, so everything you did and said was correct, all your math is fine, etc. Now it comes down to whether or not you want to trade the set off seperately for C$ or take its value rarity wise. If you’re patient enough to find someone who is okay with trading lists for C$, especially a main list, than this is the best route to go on. However keep in mind that trading ONTO the list, especially higher up, with just C$ is rather tricky and will take time. C$ is used as more of just a filler in trades, not really the main part. In my personal opinion, I would take the list pets for the set, specifically bid 3, as they’re overpaying a fair amount.

[Lucikan]

Can I get an opinion on this?

Thank you in advance! ^^

[Zelfie]

is this fair?

Need help! Please respond <3

[zankeet]

Fair? Thanks in advance c:

[popping star]

Fair? Thanks in advance c:

It is fair.
Both sides equal to 3 '09 rares.

[maxyjax]

I’m unsure if this is a fair trade because I have a 2010 uncommon in the trade. Thoughts?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=75633086&userid=880174&signature=ecG0mJuGgblerUWpxiClZw